Historians Dispute Analogies To Germany

Posted on 11/06/2003 by Juan

Historians Dispute Analogies to Germany, Japan, with Iraq

The Bush administration has continually compared the situation of post war Iraq with that of Germany and Japan under occupation after WW II. At one point, administration spokesmen even alleged that US troops in Germany had faced attacks by “Werewolves” or former SS men. This allegation is unfounded. No US troops were killed by Werewolves in post-War Germany, and they assassinated maybe one mayor, though I understand that is controversial.

Likewise, the administration of Japan was by old New Dealers who strengthed trade unions and democratized. The major projects of the Bush administration in Iraq have been to dissolve existing unions, to completely throw open the country to unregulated investment (which could easily turn speculative and predatory), and to install a regressive flat tax that will favor the emergence of super-rich robber barons.

Daniel Jahn has a great story on all this:

http://www.iol.co.za/index.php?sf=2813&click_id=2813&art_id=iol1068101125208U262&set_id=6

0 Retweet 0 Share 0 StumbleUpon 0 Printer Friendly Send via email

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off | Print

Comments are closed.

  • Juan Cole

    Juan Cole

    Welcome to Informed Comment, where I do my best to provide an independent and informed perspective on Middle Eastern and American politics.

    Informed Comment is made possible by your support. If you value the information and essays, I make available and write here, please take a moment to contribute what you can.

  • IC Destinations



  • Keep up with Informed Comment at:

    Informed Comment LinkedIn Google's Feedburner

  • Donate to Global Americana Institute

    Donate to the Global Americana Institute to support the translation into Arabic of books about America.

  • Friends and Interlocutors:

    Josh Marshall | Truthdig| The Nation | DailyKos |Tomdispatch.com | Michael Hudson (MEI Singapore)  | Kevin Drum (Mother Jones) | Mondoweiss | Salon.com | Think Progress | Helena Cobban | Huffingtonpost  |Syria Comment | Marc Lynch | WashingtonNote | Stephen Walt  | Kamil Pasha | Andrew Sullivan | George Packer | Glenn Greenwald | Read between the Lines. | Nir Rosen
    Napoleon's Egypt Blog

  • Recent Posts

  • Recent Comments

    • Iraq Comes to Syria (5)
      • JTMcPhee: The physics of politics: Legitimacy = (decency + stability)/(corruption*violenc e).
      • joe from Lowell: No, he meant “psychological warfare.” The audience for that story (if Prof. Cole is...
    • Omar Khayyam (23) (11)
      • Q: The fish is asking if there is life after death (will water return.) Khayyam is very clever, although he believes...
      • Barnett Rubin: It means: Oh take the cash and let the credit go, Nor heed the warning of a distant drum.
    • Omar Khayyam (24) (6)
      • Vanessa Gezari: I love this, Juan!
      • Q: Doings (the breaths that is taken) are real. Feelings( unbelief, religion, doubt, certainty) are appearances, only...

  • Archives

  • Categories