Amara Base Looted as British Withdraw
Qadiri Sufi Order Declared Jihad on Americans, Shiites
Things did not go well in Iraq on Friday according to WaPo.
First, the British withdrew from Camp Abu Naji near Amara. They only gave the Iraqis one day notice. This short notice suggests that the evacuation was done under considerable duress; one suspects that the British position was becoming untenable because of repeated Shiite guerrilla attacks (there were only 1200 British troops there). When they left, they left behind nearly $300,000 in equipment, intending that the Iraqi police should have the use of the base.
Muqtada al-Sadr and his followers on the provincial Governing Council crowed that the Mahdi Army was the first Iraqi group to force a substantial withdrawal of Coalition troops from an Iraqi territory, according to Amit Paley. The LA Times says that the Mahdi Army boasted of having forced the British troops to leave so abruptly.
While a small contingent of Iraqi security forces (mainly recruited from the Badr Corps and the Mahdi Army) was on the base, they professed themselves helpless when some 5000 looters, some armed with AK 47 machine guns, showed up to strip it bare. The poor British officer corps was reduced to maintaining that the camp had been kept in perfectly good order on their departure. God, they must hate Blair.
The day before, the Iraqi troops at the base briefly mutinied when they were told of a plan to transfer them to Baghdad. They were from local families and complained that this was a plan to "get rid of them." The government relented and left them in Amara. It may as well have. If they couldn't stop the looting of their own base on their home turf, what good would they have been in Baghdad?
Then in Ramadi, guerrillas holed up in the Abdul Qadir al-Kailani Mosque attacked US troops. The latter returned fire, and ultimately brought up M1 Abrams tanks and fired at the religious building. It was left with structural damage to its dome and minaret. The guerrillas set the US troops up for a lose/lose situation. By subjecting the mosque to tank fire, they look to Iraqi Muslims like anti-Muslim infidels.
If you thought that attacking a mosque associated with the great Sufi saint Abdul Qadir Gilani (Kailani) might anger members of his Qadiri Sufi order around the world, you'd be right.
Paley also reports:
' In other developments, the head of a major Iraqi sect of Sufism, a mystical branch of Islam that had previously rejected violence against U.S.-led coalition forces, declared holy war on American troops. The leader, Sheik Mohammed al-Qadiri, said his sect would form a new group, the Battalions of Sh[e]ikh Abdul Qadir al-Gaillani, and join the insurgency.
"We will not wait for the Mahdi Army and the Badr Brigade to enter our houses and kill us," said Ahmed al-Soffi, a Sufi leader in the western city of Fallujah, referring to the country's major Shiite militias. "We will fight the Americans and the Shiites who are against us." '
Al-Zaman reports that [Ar.] two civilians were killed and another wounded in an armed clash between Mahdi Army militiamen and Sunni worshippers who were guarding the Great al-Batha' Mosque in the western side of Nasiriyyah (a southern, largely Shiite city). Local police sources said that the battle between the two has been going on for the past two days. Apparently the Mahdi Army is attempting to seize the 11 Sunni mosques in the south, in Amara, Karbala, Najaf, Basra and Samawah, and turn them into Shiite places of worship. The Sadrists generally maintain that Sunni mosques in the south of the country were planted there by Saddam Hussein with money stolen from the Iraqi people, and that therefore southern Shiites are within their rights to take these mosques over. Police in Dhi Qar province, fearful that the situation will worsen, imposed a curfew beginning last Thursday evening throughout the province.
Abdul Mahdi al-Karbala'i, the representative of Grand Ayatollah Ali Sistani in the holy city of Karbala, ridiculed secular politicians who are hiding in the fortified Green Zone, calling on them to get out among the people so as to see their suffering.
Rapid rises in the prices of fuel and food have imposed severe hardship on most Iraqis at a time of high unemployment and at most flat wages. A lot of anger is building over the issue.
Security has collapsed in oil-rich Kirkuk. al-Zaman says 3 bodies were found there on Friday.
Reuters reports civil war violence for Friday. The list is incomplete, and al-Zaman reports a number of other deaths. Between the two, I'd say they report over 20 deaths from such causes on Friday, and we know that these two also missed provincial incidents.
The head of Iraqi antiquities has fled, in fear of his life. By the way, he mentions Sadrists taking over the ministry, which is ironic, since they are reputed to fund themselves by antiquities smuggling . . .


11 Comments:
Sistani's representative didn't specify secular politicians. He was critical of ministers.
Anyway, I am sure that they are, like most people in the world, aware that things are very bad indeed.
Nearly all the important ministers are Turbans: fundamentalists or Kurds. Their main task is to further themselves and groups.
Moreover, few of them actually have any clue about what to do. The Finance minister is no other than the ex-Interior minister. The hooligan who is a member of the Badr gang: literally attached to the Iranian Revolutionary Guards. The oil minister went to Iran to arrange for fuel imports although Iran is rationing and importing fuel itself because of limited refinery capacity. He also wants US oil companies (surprise!!) to come to Iraq (they would be slaughtered on arrival.)
Sistani is as responsible as the Americans for putting these freaks in government. Saying "be good" now does not absolve the religious leaders. They should have kept well out of politics.
The only solution is to call a spade a spade and declare a national state of emergency. Replace all ministers with respected apolitical technocrats. Parliament's approval wont be needed, and it should be suspended anyway.
There is an excellent new book about the CPA/British effort in Amara, "Prince of the Marshes", by Rory Stewart. All their work is evidently down the drain.
Dear Professor Cole,
Thank you so much for your hard work keeping us all informed.
Here is another interesting link. A Nuremburg Prosecutor, Benjamin Ferencz, says President Bush should be tried for war crimes related to launching an "aggressive" war in Iraq. http://us.oneworld.net/article/view/138319/1/
I can see why by your revealing accounts each day.
The story of the flight of the Iraqi Director of Antiquities, Dr. Donny George, to Damascus is a bit more complicated than you have it. I have no doubt that the Sadrists have a particularly primitive approach to antiquities and archaeology, though many others also engage in antiquities smuggling.
Dr. George has worked tirelessly since the invasion in 2003, to protect and recover the antiquities pillaged from the museum at that time. I have the highest admiration for what he has done. He was and is the right person to interface with Western archaeologists, for the recovery of smuggled artifacts and getting help from Western institutions. On the other hand, he was and is definitely the wrong person to interface with Islamists, such as the Sadrists, as he was notable for having zero interest in Islamic antiquities. It is easy to see that there was simply a personality clash, which could however have very serious consequences for the future of antiquities in Iraq (which are in a very difficult situation anyway).
Zero interest in Islamic antiquities is quite common among archaeologists who work on Iraq (and indeed other countries of the Arab world). However, what is legitimate, if short-sighted, for a US or European professor of archaeology, is not right for a director responsible for the antiquities of a country.
I've been campaigning for more than 10 years now to interest Muslims, and indeed Islamists, in their archaeological heritage, by encouraging and publicising archaeology of the Islamic period, as the best means of protecting antiquities of all periods in the Arab world. As you can imagine, I have had little success with archaeologists, who continue to pour hundreds of thousands of dollars, euros and pounds into restoring statues at Karnak, or putting up another column at Ephesus (until the next earthquake).
Now, because of short-sightedness, we may be faced with a much more serious catastrophe, if the Antiquities organisation in Baghdad falls apart.
First, the British withdrew from Camp Abu Naji near Amara.
Prof. Cole has mentioned Mr. Rory Stewart once (5 March 2005) but not in connection with his book Prince of the Marshes, which is about when he was District Officer at Amara at British Imperialism's last gasp, circa 2003-2004.
Part of the fun here is that half of Her Majesty's Haberdashers, or whatever the Brit military outfit calls itself, have supposedly now taken to the marshes and deserts themselves in a parody of Mr. T. E. Lawrence.
Rule, Britannia!
It's hard to see how any of this points to the turning of any corner in the Bush Administration's plan (?) to "win" in Iraq. On the other hand, Robert Dreyfuss reports in the Washington Monthly that a plan is afoot in the name of the Iraq Study Group to somehow convince the US president to change course. Probably will be too little, too late.
Thanks for the reality checks. From the MSM you'd swear we'd "turned a corner" again!
Great information as always Professor Cole, but I'd be more cautious in a quote such has you had:
"Then in Ramadi, guerrillas holed up in the Abdul Qadir al-Kailani Mosque attacked US troops. The latter returned fire, and ultimately brought up M1 Abrams tanks and fired at the religious building."
I'd report it as "according to the US military" since I noticed that is the source of information on the events. Given that the US military has often given false information there's no way to know what really happened.
Professor Cole:
> ' In other developments, the head of a major Iraqi sect of Sufism, a mystical branch of Islam that had previously rejected violence against U.S.-led coalition forces, declared holy war on American troops. The leader, Sheik Mohammed al-Qadiri, said his sect would form a new group, the Battalions of Sh[e]ikh Abdul Qadir al-Gaillani, and join the insurgency
.
...and to think that all we had to do was one simple thing... surround the Pentagon with a human circle, chant aum, and the building would have glowed purple and levitated... the spirits of evil entombed within would have fled to the nether realms, and a double rainbow would have appeared over the Potomac.
But Nooooooo! The 'Left' flunks up AGAIN! Damn MOBE 'marshals'!
...and now it's come to this...
Mystical assaults by "the Battalions of Sh[e]ikh Abdul Qadir al-Gaillani".
kismet.
Spinproof :
The only solution is to call a spade a spade and declare a national state of emergency. Replace all ministers with respected apolitical technocrats. Parliament's approval wont be needed, and it should be suspended anyway.
Allawi himself couldn't have put it better!
Allawi certainly couldn't John Francis Lee.
1) He is fiddling with a 'roadmap for reconcilliation'.. for the Turbans!! What folly.
2) As an ex-Baathist, ex-CIA, ex-totally failed PM, he is neither respected nor aploitical
3) He wants to be the boss, which means a coup d'etat. Extra chaos and bloodshed. I am saying the elected PM stays.
Post a Comment
<< Home