Mortar Shells Kill Dozens of Shiites in East Baghdad
Iraq to take over Dhi Qar Province
Reuters reports political violence throughout the country, which left at least 67 dead and dozens wounded.
In the single biggest incident, Mortar shells slammed into a Shiite neighborhood in East Baghdad, causing a building to collapse on inhabitants and killing at least 50 (a number sure to rise as the building is excavated).
See, it really doesn't matter that much if the number of overall attacks falls in Baghdad. What matters is how angry sectrian groups are with one another. I sympathize with the difficulty the US and Iraqi militaries have in combatting such random mortar attacks. How could you really stop such things if someone is determined to carry them out? But the rage among Shiites will certainly produce reprisals, and a downward spiral of hatred that is ethnically cleansing Baghdad.
I was talking to my taxi driver today, who is an Iraqi Shiite and a recognized ceramics artist who taught in art school in Iraq but doesn't have good enough English to do that here. I asked him where he was from. He said his family is from Babil but he grew up in Baghdad. I said, where? Karrada? He said, no, al-Mansur, near Ghazaliyah. I said, I thought those were mostly Sunni areas. He replied, well, they are now. He thought the only chance of stopping the violence before 20 years was to go ahead and partition the country into three but to make sure there is an over all Federal government that shares out the petroleum receipts equitably with all three. I guess Senator Biden has some Iraqi supporters. I don't think that would be a good idea. Just remember East Bengal in the original Pakistan.
Al-Hayat says that Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki [Ar.] has announced that Italian and Romanian troops will turn the southern province of Dhi Qar, with its capital of Nasiriyah, over to Iraqi security forces in September. Dhi Qar would be the second province where the Iraqi government has regained its sovereignty. The first was the small sleepy southern province of Muthanna. The second was scheduled to be Maysan, but the looting of the base from which the British recently withdrew near Amara will not have inspired confidence.
"The Iraqi Army" in the South seems to include a lot of local tribal levies. The tribes of the Middle Euphrates are especially loyal to Grand Ayatoollah Ali Sistani. That is, they may be a kind of third party militia rather than really a national army.

|
Facebook




7 Comments:
I was talking to my taxi driver today, who is an Iraqi Shiite... He thought the only chance of stopping the violence before 20 years was to go ahead and partition the country into three...
I think the neocons agree with your cabdriver and are working hard to partition Iraq by fanning, not stopping the violence.
I feel sure that when the dust is settled we will discover that the neocons have funded and equipped the terrorists in Iraq on both sides of the Sunni/Shiite divide that they have so "tenderly" nurtured, just as they did twenty years and more ago in El Salvador. It's the SAME PEOPLE, people.
And I'm sure we'll be SHOCKED! to discover the depths of depravity these most depraved of us Americans have sunk to.
Again.
A bad marriage always better than divorce--always? Were the Balkans better off as a single Yugoslavia under Serbian rule? Should the Baltics be part of Russia? Czechs and Slovakians make better neighbors than spouses.
Looks like Baghdad is already going through a violent breakup, even in a unitary Iraq. Once it is fully ghettoized or "cleansed," the partitioning will be a reality. At that point, a three or four state solution will be viable--for the Shia and Kurds. Sunnis will howl that a particion is unworkable, but their rejection of majority rule makes a single Iraq even more unworkable. None of the Iraqi mini-states would be democratic, but neither is the present situation encouraging. Larry Diamond no longer seems very sanguine. AEI people no longer have anything to say bout Iraq and bet all their chips on an aerial assault on Iran: better luck with plutonium than politics.
Watching an Arab network Wednesday night (I did not notice which one the piece was extracted from) but it was on how much things had improved in Baghdad with traffic returning to normal and shops opening again and people patronizing the shops. They interviewed one old woman with an open air fresh vegetable stand. The point was that the media is ignoring the good news in Iraq and how much of the violence is generated by nonArabs (rather pointedly meaning the Iranians, with references to Persians funding violence against Arabs) and how Arabs needed to stand together against outside agitators.
It was rather amazing and was not Lebanese or Israeli so my guess has to be that it was a US sponsored network.
I hope we are not selling this pie in the sky, rainbow stew, over the top propaganda as real news but I have the uneasy feeling that subtlety is not our strong suit in the Middle East.
RE: "See, it really doesn't matter that much if the number of overall attacks falls in Baghdad..."
insofar as the American public and media are concerned, the only metric that matters is the number of uniformed military personnel in IRAQ Killed In Action; eg.:
Note "the KIA Index" number is only Americans ~ total "coalition" KIA are rarely reported; and, for some perverse reason, allied IRAQI military & police are not even considered members of the Iraq Coalition!
Note that the wounded are rarely reported, and when they are, this "20,000" number bantyed about is almost always vague. With such an emphasis on "the KIA Index" made-for-media benchmark, by the miracle of modern battlefield medicine, a dis-proportionate number of the GWOT casualties are doomed to living hell destinies, not unlike that depicted in the film, "Johnny Got His Gun".
And it's not just BUSH: That the Americans do not honour their war dead is... bizarre; that they do not acknowledge their own wounded casualties is... merciless; but that they do not even recognize those IRAQIS who are killed and/or wounded while fighting along side them... is RACIST: shame!
The Civil War raging in Iraq shows daily the abject failure of the Bush Administration (which the American people to their discredit elected twice).
It exposes the complete failure of massive military force in guerilla warfare and the profound misunderstanding of those who make American foreign policy decisions.
Unfortunately Americans in the main are not people who can admit they got it badly wrong and Bush certainly won't. Creates rather a hiatus, doesn't it?
London's Daily Telegraph (right wing) reports that Ali Sistani is giving up on politics. That will leave a vacuum for somebody else to fill.
RE: your taxi driver says to partition and you disagree.
Partitioning accompanied by a formal confederation is essential now. Big rush to topple the statue and get the oil left the borders unsecured and the arms caches wide open. Foolish and greedy Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld.
We dont have the luxury of following their madness any longer. Confederation by partition into three main factions: Shia, Sunni and Kurd, create provisional international city of Bagdad under jurisdiction of the UN. Share oil revenues equitably with restriction for food, medical and rebuilding only. No weapons. You buy or make weapons with oil money, you are cut off. Added bonus: commitment for US troops OUT by EASTER. OUT. No equivocating. The Marines go where they belong, on ships, ready to pounce if needed.
Now the difficult part. We dont have a Commander in Chief who knows what "when they are needed" means. We need a new Senate asserting its Constitutional DUTIES (you want to be a senator, you have to make the tough decisions). We wont get a new Senate and congress with budget authority unless the Democrat (that's right, I like Democrat Party tag , stick in their face) Party stands up an advances something that will calm the madness. This fantasy that the so-called "Iraqi people" have to figure out how to stop the mess we created (this is my congresswoman's response) is absurd. Resolutions telling Bush to do that is a waste of time. Stand on the tarmack and honor the dead and wounded as they return. Vow to not let that happen under a Democrat congress and administration. Advocate for the American service people and Get them HOME. Advocate for the people of the area labeled by the former British empire as "Iraq" and let them sort out their own destiny.
Show some leadership, vision, compassion and guts Democrats.If you toss pebbles and call names and profer resolutions, you will wake up Nov 8,still a minority and the carnage continues.
Harry Jay Powell, Veteran and Chaplain for the Common Good.
Post a Comment
<< Home