Informed Comment

Thoughts on the Middle East, History, and Religion

Juan Cole is President of the Global Americana Institute

Friday, March 23, 2007

4 US GIs Killed
House Dems set to Pass '08 Withdrawal Language
Shiite on Shiite Violence in Basra


House Speaker Nancy Pelosi appears to have put together a winning bill by both authorizing additional funding for US troops in Iraq and Afghanistan (something antiwar Democrats oppose) and by specifying a withdrawal date of 2008 (something the antiwar representatives very much want). The danger for her was that the antiwar left would peel away and she might not have the votes to pass the bill, which Republicans will vote against in the main. But most close observers of the Hill on Thursday were convinced that Pelosi would win this one.

The Senate Appropriations Committee seems set, a little unexpectedly, to report out a similar bill with the withdrawal language in it. Because of the Senate's provisions for filibuster and consensual decision-making, however, it seems very unlikely that the language will survive when it goes to the whole Senate.

Bush has promised to veto any bill sent him with the withdrawal language in it.

UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon made a surprise visit to Baghdad Thursday, holding a joint news conference with Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki. As the PM was speaking, the auditorium was shaken by a katyusha rocket that landed only 50 yards away. Al-Maliki apparently has nerves of steel and did not even flinch, but Ban Ki-moon ducked at the sound of the blast. Al-Maliki had been in the midst of asserting that the security situation in Iraq was improving.

Reuters reports political violence in Iraq. Guerrillas killed three US troops on Wednesday, it was announced, and another on Thursday.

44 persons were killed or found dead around Iraq on Thursday, according to the wire services, including 25 bodies that showed up in the streets of Baghdad.

There was a prison riot in Basra, with inmates revolting on the grounds that they had been held 2-4 years without trial.

Clashes broke out in Basra between the Sadr Movement and the Islamic Virtue Party or Fadhila. The violence left 7 persons wounded, and city authorities imposed a curfew. Al-Hayat reports in Arabic that Mahdi Army militiamen burned down the major HQ of the Islamic Virtue Party after having invaded the offices of the electricity administration and having expelled its employees and imprisoned the manager. The two parties were said to be vying over control of a building that the British authorities had been using but which they had recently abandoned. The attack on the electricity administration offices came about, it was alleged, because the director had disciplined an electricity worker from the Mahdi Army. Some observers say that this conflict presages what is likely to happen in Basra when the British leave.

Al-Hayat reports in Arabic that the speaker of the Iraqi parliament, Mahmud al-Mashhadani, has compared the Mahdi Army to al-Qaeda in Iraq as among the most dangerous threats to Iraqi security. The Sadrist members of parliament vehemently rejected this characterization. MP Qusay Abdul Wahhab said that the Mahdi Army is just the Iraqi Resistance, that it has been dormant for several months, and that the real threat to Iraq comes from radical Sunni Arabs who excommunicate all Muslims who do not think like them (especially Shiites, whom they target for killing).

US troops found caches of chlorine and nitric acid in guerrilla storehouses in the Ghazaliya district of Baghdad on Thursday, raising the specter that the guerrillas are increasingly turning to chemical weapons. They have conducted several attacks using chlorine gas.

The US is attempting to avert a potentially disastrous Turkish military intervention in Iraqi Kurdistan. The Turks accuse Kurdistan of harboring 3600 guerrillas of the radical Kurdish Workers' Party (PKK), who, it says, are committing acts of terrorism in eastern Anatolia and then slipping back over the border into Iraq. Turkish Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul is threatening hot pursuit by Turkish troops across that border. Such an incursion could set off the tinderbox that is northern Iraq.

Prince Hassan of Jordan supports Turkey in this regard. He warns against an ethno-religious breakup of Iraq, saying it will lead to the Balkanization of the entire Middle East.

Total's CEO has been detained in connection with a bribery charge related to Total's interest in Iranian petroleum.

Iraqi Christians are being forced to flee their country by the violence and because they are sometimes targeted by Sunni Arab guerrillas who wrongly associate them with the West. This article estimates them at 5% of the Iraqi population, which is probably incorrect. There were 800,000 or so of them before the war, but my understanding is that they may be down to 500,000 now, which would make them 2 percent of the population. Likewise, it strikes me as highly unlikely that 40% of Iraqis fleeing the country are Christian. The vast majority of Iraqi expatriates (some 800,000) in Jordan are Sunni Arabs, e.g.

There is so little safe water in Iraq that this summer a major cholera epidemic could break out, the UN is warning.

Labels:

4 Comments:

At 8:33 AM, Blogger ivorybill said...

I read the Guardian article and wanted to offer some comments on Turkey and Iraqi Kurdistan. We work in these communities, including Kani Masi (referred to in the article) and also with Iranian Kurdish refugees living in the KRG.

The KRG does not support the Iranian version of the PKK because they recognize the need to maintain a relationship with Iran. PUK is particularly opposed, and I really doubt KDP is supporting them because the only section of the Iranian border the KDP controls is near Baradost, and Karim Khan the local agha has always attempted to avoid conflict with PUK.

Opposition to the Iranian PKK is a widespread sentiment among government officials and common citizens - nobody wants to piss off Iran, and the mood toward Iran is actually better these days than at times in the past. Most of the Iranian Kurdish refugees in northern Iraq are Komala (communist party) or KDPI. The KRG does not grant refuge to PKK Iran partisans, and will not tolerate the presence of the terrorist group MEK for the same reason.

I have a hard time figuring out how the CIA could be supporting these PKK Iran guys around the back of the KRG. We work right inside the Iranian camps in Diyana, Khanaqin and also on the border, and there is no evidence whatsoever for this sort of thing. Far less, in fact, than evidence of PKK Turkey involvement in the Makhmur camp near Erbil. In that camp, PKK fighters (unarmed) would occasionally visit the residents, mostly their relatives, and it is clear where the sympathies of the camp residents lies.

The opposite is true of Iranian Kurdish refugees in Diyana, Khanaqin or inside the cities in the north. The PKK Iran is simply not welcome, and some of their fighters end up in Susa prison north of Suleymaniya if they are caught.

PUK forces attack PKK units from time to time, including the PKK Iran - the most recent clash I heard about was above Raniya in the Pishdar region, and occurred about two months ago. The PUK and KDP can't control the area as thoroughly as before because some of their best units are in Mosul, Baghdad and Kirkuk, and because they are still tracking Ansar al-Islam sympathizers down in Hawraman. Inability to control an area is a different thing than support, which is what Turkey alleges.

I think that Turkey is alleging cross-border CIA involvement from Iraqi Kurdistan to Iranian Kurdistan because it plays well at home. The Guardian article cites a Turkish academic source and Abdullah Gul. Gul can no more be trusted than Condoleeza Rice, and the academic may not be reliable unless he truly has some independence from the government. I can't judge that, but if he is an ethnic Turk, he has no real on-the-ground knowledge of the border. One needs to take Turkish government and nationalist movement allegations with a big grain of salt because they manipulate the Kurdish issue the same way the Bush Administration manipulates the War on Terror.

There are certainly PKK on Qandil and other mountains along the border. However, from having actually been to Kani Masi and hiked on Qandil mountain, I believe that the Turkish estimate of 3,600 is absurd - the PKK is mostly teenagers and a few experienced fighters, shivering up there in the mountains and occasionally staging raids. Who knows what the true number is, but there are not big encampments up there or a highly organized guerilla force. The PKK has plenty of local support on the Turkish side of the border, and a PKK guerilla doesn't need to go to Iraq to get a gun or be protected. In fact the opposite is true - the Iraq-Turkey border is quite dangerous, and most PKK fighters are better off avoiding it altogether.

In terms of what Turkey will do... I think Turkey is not likely to invade in a major way, because every couple months they threaten this sort of action. However, they are starting the process of convincing Turkish citizens to support eventual military action in Iraq. Not right away, but in the future, and perhaps over Kirkuk. However, the issue is not rooting out the PKK. The issue is Turkish fear of Iraqi Kurdish identity and its long-term effects on Turkey's Kurdish population. Those armed teenagers up there on Qandil mountain are just bait - Turkey will kill them sooner or later on the Turkish side of the border anyway. So Turkey will figure out ways to demonize the Iraqi Kurds, accuse them of never doing enough, but is unlikely to invade in force until after the US leaves. When they do, it will be a tragedy for both Turkey and Iraqi Kurdistan. They are likely to find that subjugating the Kurds in Iraq is going to be a whole lot tougher than subjugating Hizbullah in Lebanon.

 
At 1:48 PM, Blogger LJansen said...

So the war is safe! Thank goodness. Dems have their pork and Bush will take out the withdrawal deadline.

Could there be a happier result (unless you're an Iraqi, in the US military or a US taxpayer).

 
At 1:50 PM, Blogger Murteza ali said...

Credit where credit is due, Nuri al Maliki has got Tungsten balls. The UN Sec Gen ducked and almost hid under the table while maliki barely blinked.

YouTube the video, im sure itll be floating around the net.

 
At 7:25 PM, Blogger Michael Murry said...

I find it utterly ridiculous that Speaker Pelosi can claim a "victory" for browbeating her own Democratic Party into giving Cheney and Bush more money for their lies and bloody incompetence while letting the Republicans who favor and always have favored these liars and incompetents of theirs vote against "supporting the troops" and get away with it. Stunning stupidity. Deputy Dubya will simply cross the fingers of one hand held behind his back, "sign" the supplemental (meaning, "off the books" with no "pay as you go" revenue provided) bill, snarl: "kiss my scrawny, lying ass" with yet another "unsigning" statement, and go right on with the pointless and needless occupation of Iraq until he pulls the same stunt next year and then leaves office to forever blame his successors for what he and Sheriff Dick did.

No spending bill would have put a necessary end to every last bit of this charade. No president can veto no spending bill. No Senate can undermine no spending bill. No mendacious and duplicitous "bait and switch" President can sign-then-unsign no spending bill. By far-seeing design of the founders of our Republic, lack of agreement in the House of Representatives on funding a dangerous standing army would deprive any president of the opportunity to abuse that standing army in pursuit of his own partisan political, if not kingly, ambitions. I guess Speaker Pelosi has never read the Federalist Papers where Alexander Hamilton explained all this Power of the Purse stuff. Too stupid to stipulate, really, and a complete validation of Ralph Nader's dictum that you can't find a dime's worth of difference, when it really matters, between the two right wings (Democratic and Republican) of America's single, corporate faction with its two Janus faces.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home