Informed Comment

Thoughts on the Middle East, History, and Religion

Juan Cole is President of the Global Americana Institute

Thursday, March 08, 2007

Cole in Salon: "Is the Bush Surge already Failing

My bi-weekly column at Salon.com is out:


'
Is the Bush surge already failing?

The president just gave a rosy assessment of his plan, but insurgents have adapted and Iraqis continue to be slaughtered. . .

Soldiers from the 2nd Brigade of the 82nd Airborne Division and Iraqi National policemen patrol the Shiite enclave of Sadr City in Baghdad, Iraq, on March 6, 2007.

March 8, 2007 | On Tuesday, President Bush said that "even at this early hour, there are some encouraging signs" that the so-called surge is working in Iraq. In fact, three weeks into what the president refers to as the "surge" and what Iraqis call the "new security plan," it's already clear that Bush's last-gasp bid for victory faces challenges that can't necessarily be surmounted by a few thousand additional troops.

With plenty of warning of the U.S. escalation, the Shiite Mahdi Army is lying low. Meanwhile, the Iraqi army and the much better equipped and trained U.S. military have made no appreciable progress against the real drivers of the country's civil war, Sunni Arab guerrillas, who have so far adapted successfully to the new deployments. And perhaps most important, a new spate of massive and deadly bombings has spread insecurity and further compromised the Iraqi government. '


Read the whole thing.

Guerrillas killed three US troops on Wednesday northwest of Baghdad.

In Iraq on Wednesday, major violence continued against Iraq pilgrims and the police guarding them. Guerrillas detonated a car bomb in the southern Baghdad district of Saidiya, which killed a policeman and 7 Shiite pilgrims, and wounded 27. In Iskandariya south of Baghdad, guerrillas lobbed mortar shells at Shiite pilgrims, killing 6 and wounding 13.

In the small city of Baladruz northeast of Baghdad, Sunni Arab guerrillas bombed a cafe, killing 30 and wounding 25.

Altogether, the wire services reported 90 dead in violence for Wednesday.

Al-Zaman reports in Arabic that the Islamic Virtue Party (Fadila), with 15 seats in parliament, has announced that it is withdrawing from the United Iraqi Alliance, the coalition of Shiite fundamentalist parties. Leader Nadim al-Jabiri said the move was intended to underline the need of Iraqi parties to leave behind the sectarian framework that has bedevilled the country's politics. But the Virtue Party first began talking about withdrawing when it was not given the ministry of petroleum.

An Israeli newspaper, Maariv, is reporting that a retired Israeli officer has been exporting high-powered weapons to Iraqi guerrillas. The report is summarized in English here.

7 Comments:

At 6:31 AM, Blogger bittersweet said...

I was listening to an interview of General Petraeus by the BBC this morning in which he was outlining his plans and his need for more troops in order to secure safety in areas which have been cleansed. He stressed the need for political support and action in order to achieve a working government. He also said that there had never been enough troops nor the right kind of troops in Iraq to achieve the goal set out by the administration. All those years of reassurance from Rumsfeld that everything was okay. Now the truth is emerging from a qualified leader. Is Bush setting him up along with a few thousand fighting men and women and a few hundred thousand Iraqui's?

 
At 9:13 AM, Blogger Syrian Nationalist Party said...

It's hopeless.

 
At 9:40 AM, Blogger John Koch said...

Ret. Major Shmuel Avivi, former military attaché to Denmark and Switzerland, now senior executive of the arms broker Talon Ltd, must be a very interesting person. Taos Industries, of Madison, Alabama also operates in an interesting niche. Strange these sorts of enterprises appear to be off limits to US media. One wonders if they are also off limits to the GAO, Pentagon OIG, or CIA. The greatest story never told? Perhaps it's safer to stick to exposés of military hospitals.

 
At 10:16 AM, Blogger Kevin Hayden said...

Petraeus is calling for talks with militant groups saying military force alone won't do it.

Kevin Hayden
American Street

 
At 3:58 PM, Blogger Matteo Tomasini said...

When are they going to realize that there is no military solution to the conflict in Iraq. $93.4 billion for the DoD, and we still fall short of fully funding economic development in Iraq. Shameful. That is why Amnesty International, Mercy Corps, the Iraq Foundation and 37 other national NGO's have joined together to send a letter to Congress demanding that the administration include more development funds in its 2007 supplemental.

 
At 10:40 PM, Blogger james_speaks said...

"An Israeli newspaper is reporting that a retired Israeli officer has been exporting high-powered weapons to Iraqi guerrillas.Ma'ariv Daily has reported that an Israeli retired officer sells weapons to terrorist groups in Iraq."

The article states:

"Shmoel Avivi, an Israeli retired officer, had established a firm in Iraq 2 years ago, which secretly sold arms to terrorist groups in Iraq, Ma'ariv reported.

Amnesty International reported that Avivi was one of the biggest weapon dealers in the Middle East."


Interesting news, but it is an Israeli so it must be right? Right?

Let's try the rose_by_another_name test.

*A retired Syrian General is selling arms to Iraqi insurgents.*

(No, not really.)

Now, what to do? We launch Stealth bombers, of course and take out.....(now let's switch back to Israeli general) and whoops, either we have to recall those bombers or else we do the unthinkable, and we will never do the unthinkable, nor think the unthinkable nor even allow ourselves to suggest the unthinkable because, like all good Americans, we continue to think inside the nice box AIPAC has placed us in (because Israel is our special friend and we need Israel).

 
At 12:12 PM, Blogger ent lord said...

According to IBA, Elhanan Tannenbaum, the Israeli businessman and reserve IDF officer who was kidnapped by Hibullah is now being courtmartialed by the IDF. This unusual event is because it is alleged that he was in Lebanon to arrange a drug deal. The deal evidently went bad and he was kidnapped.
He was part of the prisoner exchange in 2004 but this news puts a tarnish on the deal it seems.
Gaining the release of an IDF officer is one thing and gaining the freedom of a drug kingpin is another.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home