We don't have Mousavi supporters, it's now all of Iran...
Report on Tuesday's Demonstration for Mousavi in Tehran from an eyewitness. Again, I was sent this by an academic, but will not give the name to avoid any repercussions for the individual.
Today, under slate skies and despite official warnings that the permit to march had been denied, against rumors that orders had been given to shoot to kill, they came. They came by the tens if not hundreds of thousands, marching east to west along the many kilometers of Enqelab Street to Azadi, or Freedom Square. "It would be dishonorable, na mardi, to not go," a young couple explained. "We have to go." Another man asks who is going, what is going on? He is told that the "Mousavi-chiha" are marching starting at 4. He laughs, "Mousavi-chiha nadarim, hame ye Iran hastand!" We don't have Mousavi supporters, it's now all of Iran...
That they came to Azadi, a place where thirty years ago the Revolution pivoted towards victory was fitting, for as much as the election campaign had been about who best represented the revolutionary values of Iran, Islam, and the late Imam, the push and pull of the past few days between opposition and Ahmadinejad forces has been a struggle to lay claim to authenticity. Authenticity that lies in the imagined and lived past, places, and practices of the Islamic Republic. It is as if whomever can get to the important places and rituals first and stay there, hang onto them, will win. So at night, beginning at 9 pm, we hear shouts of "Allah Akbar!" from the rooftops, just like in the fall and winter of 1978-1979. We have marches to sacred spots like Azadi and appeals by all sides to the memory of Khomeini...
In the crowd there are families, young and old. One cannot help but notice the large presence of women of all ages. The typical daily life of the capital is out here together, the homes, sidewalks and boulevards abandoned for this shared space. There is word that the crowd is millions strong; we know that it stretches eastwards to Imam Hussein Square. It is an incredible occasion---by comparison the state-organized 200,000 strong anniversary march that takes place every February starts from around Ferdowsi Square, several kilometers closer in to Azadi.
The mood in the crowd was positive, reminiscent of the joyous celebrations of the final week of the campaign. The chants are up-to-date, changed to reflect the new circumstances in Iran, the things that we did not know before Friday's vote. "Hale ye noor e ro dide, rai e mano nadide?" A reference to the light of the hidden Imam that Ahmadinejad claimed to have seen, roughly translated to rhyme, "If he saw that light, why didn't he see the vote we cast with all our might?!" And, "Ta in Ahmadi nejad hast, in ghaziye ijad hast!" Until this Ahmadi is here, this commotion will not disappear!
There are new signs as well. Written in English, "Where is My Vote?" (I can't help myself, the idea for an Al Gore-Mir Hossein Mousavi buddy film pops into my mind, "Dude, Where is My Vote?"). Another: 2 x 2 = 24 million, a play on the bogus economic measures touted by Ahmadinejad during the debates, now updated to reflect the equally dubious election results.
The procession passes through an underpass and just as there is great pleasure in honking the car horn in tunnels these many people send up an enormous cheer, echoing off the walls. From dark to light the crowd emerges from the underpass and looks back to see what they have done. There is above them stretching across the tunnel a dissonant sight, a sign with the visage and message of the Supreme Leader. He watches over this protest in the manner of TJ Eckelberg...
The crowd knots and comes to an absolute standstill. They are pressed against each other, Cochella and Woodstock in one. Slowly, slowly the people move forward and see that the cause for the standstill is Mehdi Karrobi. Karrobi whose almost 400,000 votes was the most telling sign that something was seriously amiss with the vote count (he counted more registered activists and supports in his campaign machine alone). Karrobi, a former member of Imam Khomeini's inner circle, who during the presidential race four years ago famously protested that "I was in first place during the vote count, took an afternoon nap, and when I woke up I was suddenly two places behind Ahmadinejad." The 72 year-old cleric stands atop a car surrounded by body guards, blessing the crows with blown kisses.
As I have noted before, what is remarkable about the Mousavi and opposition marches is the orderly disorder. These are not rallies or events in the manner that we are accustomed to in the United States. There are no official Mousavi volunteers guiding the crowd to the designated rallying points, college interns filled with coffee and day-old pizza. The movement is self-directed. Mousavi had asked his supporters to march but to march respectfully, to not give any excuse for violence. The crowd is abiding. Along the nearly kilometer length of a basiji base, the cry goes up: Shoar nagoo! Don't shout slogans! Hands are up held up instead. It is quiet. Here and there a voice, unable to restrain itself, begins to scream "Allah Akbar! Allah Akbar!" He is met instantly with hisses and whistles---saket! saket! quiet! quiet!---and the voice falls silent again.
How do we know where to go? When to go? SMS or texting is down, the internet is spotty and cell phones have become unreliable. Still, Tehran has always been a city where information gets passed around easily. For all of the complaints and anxiety that life has become too modern, that people are living alone in great apartment towers instead of with their families in homes, the citizens of this city find ways to know, to be in each other's business. Conversations come easily even amongst strangers, more so now than ever. Men weave through the crowd, telling us what's next. "Come tomorrow to Vali Asr at 5! Tomorrow! Spread the word!"
Compare this to the Ahmadinejad rallies that we have seen. Yesterday, Mother's Day in Iran (an appropriate day given Ahmadinejad's persistent claim to be the "defender" of the vatan, or motherland) the Ahmadinejad groups held their own rally and show of force in Vali Asr Square in central Tehran. Their numbers are not few---the crowd filled the square and stretched south for at least a kilometer. But this action is more organized, mobilization by memo as one observer put it. Word goes out in the mosques, bonyads, and ministries that there is to be a gathering and they come, organized by section and arriving in chartered buses and vans. Unlike the Mousavi rallies, their Great Leader is present both in person and in stereo. Audio equipment is set up to so that we might hear his message and the speakers tell the crowd where to go afterwards. The atmosphere is no less festive, no less family-oriented than the opposition rallies. But the numbers are less and the movement less sustained. There is, perhaps, less to lose for this group, less sense of outrage and danger.
Back on Enqelab, the sun slips under the clouds and light begins to fall sideways across the crowds, hands turn golden in the last part of the day. Dasta bala! Dasta bala! Hands in the air! Hands in the air! All arms are up, spread into the familiar sign of victory. The crowd reaches the square but cannot enter, does not need to enter, this spot will do. On either side of a nearby underpass a call and response begins, arms and legs hang over the guardrail, bodies lean over the road that runs several meters below. From one side of the underpass: "Mir Hossein!" From the other: "Ya Hossein!" From one side: "Mir Hossein!" Now from the other: "Ya Hossein!" Cars and motorcycles raise the alarm, young men with green scarves over their faces ninja-style run and hop between the traffic. They urge the crowd and cars on, MC style. Two large passenger buses emerge from under the tunnel and the drivers lay on their horns, making the crowd go wild, they love it. It is all noise. The cheer goes up, "Gofte boodim age taqalob bishe, Iran ghiamat mishe!" We told you that if they cheat, Iran will explode!
We leave the square and head north along Jenah Expressway towards Ariashahr or Sadiqia Square. It is only at this point that the enormity of what is happening becomes clear. In the diminishing light there and stretching towards the rising foothills that mark the upper reaches of Tehran one can only see person after another. Cars and buses that have made the mistake of turning into this crowd have been engulfed.
The story takes a bad turn; all does not end well. Seeing the camera around my neck, several people rush up to me, frantically urging me to go take pictures, shouting that they are killing us all! Behind a wall, in an alleyway set off from the road, a confrontation is taking place between one spike of the crowd and basiji forces, holed up in a base. There is the unsettling pop-pop-pop of gunfire, a plume of black smoke rises into the sky. A crowd is gathering in the alley and men rush forward to throw rocks while others tell them to stop, stop, that's what they want! A police officer, alone, rushes in to help, brought in by part of the crowd. Suddenly he is surrounded, confronted violently by angry protestors. A great confusion ensues as water bottles and rocks are hurled at the cop; 10-15 men form a perimeter around the officer to shield him their hands up begging the crowd to control themselves to let this man pass, he has come to help. During the worst moment, we see the terrified policeman pressed against a courtyard wall, his hat has been knocked off, he shouts that he is here to help. Finally, thankfully, the situation is controlled, the police officer joins in the chanting, and he is allowed to go into the alley to help...
The chant goes up, the same as was used during the 1979 Revolution: "He who kills my brother, will be killed by me!"
The wail of an ambulance. A boy, he could not have been older than 14, is rushed through the crowd, carried sideways at the head and the legs by three men. Foam is coming out of his mouth and his eyes. There is no way of knowing for sure but there are reports that 5 to 7 people have been shot, have been killed right here in this spot. I see a young man hold up his right hand, it is covered in blood...
They found a way to make it last. Everyone says that in a few days the protests will be stopped, what's the point of going out, but when the moment comes everyone is here. To stop this now would take a tremendous display of violence and thus far, blessedly, that has not happened.
Still, at this point, the crowd remains uncertain...An apt if unimaginative metaphor would be a school of fish. Everyone moves in one direction, then suddenly shoulders drop and they run for their lives the opposite way. Riqdan! Riqdan! They're attacking!!! The mass looks back and sees that there are already hands held up beckoning the crowd to stop, to come back, to be brave and not run.
Fear. It would be an unfair mismatch if fear were to disappear. Do not believe the lie that this is a story of middle-class, urbane Iran set against the great multitude of obdurate peasants, the supposedly authentic Iran. That is a myth, what Juan Cole has called the "North Tehran fallacy," no different than the bogus notion that Middle America is the True America. Iran's heart and voting population lies in its cities as much as in the countryside...It was in the cities that the 1979 Revolution took place, and the 6-8 million new voters that showed up at the booth to vote, many for the first and only time in their lives, did not emerge from Iran's diminishing villages.
Tehran is fast becoming two. In the late afternoon and lasting until around dinner time it is a place of peaceful civic celebration, a disneyland of political action for the whole family to participate. At night, the mood shifts abruptly, and the capital becomes a battleground, a city in which fear stalks on motorbikes mounted in helmeted pairs...
It is like a dream. We wake up in the morning, our legs and voices sore, wondering if this is really happening, anxious for what will come next.
End/ (Not Continued)

|
21 Comments:
Your reporting on Iran has destroyed the impression I had of you, an educated scientist.
Quoting the random writings of anonymous secularists as "proof" is like quoting the reports of hardcore communists how badly they were beaten up "by the system" and how badly they are opressed.
I wonder if you are objective enough to also quote the stories of members of the Revolutionary Guard as a "proof" how the situation is in Iran.
I wonder if you are objective enough to also show the pictures of the hundreds of civilians and policemen who are hurt and tortured by the stone-throwing extremists you are glorifying.
So based on the comments of some random person on the street told to your anonymous source, we're supposed to believe it's now all of Iran and not just Mousavi supporters?
Thanks for this. Brilliant commentary, I was in Tehran in 79, exciting times.....
"We don't have Mousavi supporters, it's now all of Iran..."
Nice slogan, but not supported, as a matter of fact contradicted by the text. Of course, people who support "another" do not count, they are not Iran, right?
By the way, not a word about "peacful" protesters trying to storm a paramilitary compound - the death was a result of it. Whould they try it in USA? And with what result?
Really, Prof. Cole could not be less "informed" then me, and I see a giant gaps in his (and his sourses) arguments.
Great writeup professor Cole.
if the iranian government werent trying to supress dissent it would be easier for prof. cole to evaluate the objectivity of his sources. since the iranian regime is blocking access to information, we on the outside are entitled to assume what they are suppressing is unfavorablke to them and draw whatever inferences we like. if the iranian government doesnt want the world thinking they are tyrants, they should allow transparent news coverage. Since they are the ones concealing, i choose to believe the Cole's blog as divine revelation and if the apologists for the iranian tyranny object to that, let them provide accurate coverage to disprove it.
Let the leaders come to grips with reality. Their stubborn support of perpetual revolution has backfired. It is time to stop dreaming of an Islamic empire and building a just and thriving Persia with diversity is far more noble than this revolution.
Not all men believe in Allah, or any other god.
What courage and bravery. Amazing commentary. Thanks for giving us first hand information. Please keep more coming.
This author has no need to report the story from the view of the Republican Guard. Any militia, policeman, soldier, etc. who would fire upon their own countryman in support of a person such as Ahmadinejad, deserves to be killed. I remembered the face of Ahmadinejad, as well as the hostages held in Teheran in 1979 as being one of the leaders during the takeover of the U.S. Embassy compound. Israeli intelligence has also identified him as this hostage taker as well. He is the devil in human form. Shooting unarmed people is unfiar in all aspects. Lets arm the Mousavi supporters and let them shoot back at the police and Revolutionary Guard. Let's make it fair and balanced. I was a 14 year U.S. Army soldier and you'd better believe that this veteran soldier would be firing back if I was fired upon by the police, Army or whomever. I fully support these Mousavi supporters and I wish you all the very best in your quest for freedom and democracy in your country. I'd send Ahmadi off into exile. Take Care.
Thanks for the interesting read.
'Quoting the random writings of anonymous secularists as "proof"'
Where did anyone say anything about 'proof' of anything? This sounds about like what I have been reading/seeing everywhere.
Wow people get upset at you, I must need to read more of your website...
Who on Earth would be defending the shooting of innocent protestors, the beating with chains and clubs of random marchers, or the jailing of journalists and the shutting down of communications besides someone with an authoritarian bent to begin with?
Fine write-up, Professor Cole. Thank you.
Whilst I can see that you are not 100% unbiased, I can see that you are reporting what is really happening. Congratulations on what you are doing.
To address those who think that this is biased and that those other scenes are not reported, well that is not true. Try the Huffington Post and Andrew Sullivan for further information. Some of the above report I read at another site - I am not sure if it was Robert Fisk or somewhere else though. I have been doing a lot of reading on the subject.
This is way bigger than Mousavi and Kharoubi supporters. The 4th candidate has also put in his protest over the vote. That is interesting because he was never going to be a chance.
However, to address the other concerns regarding the Basiji building, maybe that is best explained due to the fact that the Basiji are so hated by the people. Also, Ahmadinejad has brought in Hezbollah and Syrians to do the work of the Basiji in Tehran. That in itself would get feelings running high.
The scene where a 13 year old was shot to death is one of many that were repeated elsewhere in the country. It was reported that 7 died in that spot. It was also reported that 7 were murdered at the university of Tehran (I think that is the right one). The Basiji stormed the university at night, bashing and killing the students with widespread destruction of property. That scene has been repeated elsewhere.
Also, in the middle of the night, many "enemies" of Amadinejad have been rounded up and "arrested". It is rumoured that they have been taken as hostages. All this is doing is causing the people to be all the more hostile.
The regular police and army are taking no action against the protesters. They are on their side for the most part. It is different with the Basiji.
Please Prof. Cole, keep up the good work with your reports.
Wow, I cannot believe that previous comments suggest that we need even more comments by the Iranian government to find out the truth. You think we need to go find out the truth from people instituting a media crackdown? Ridiculous.
I'm not sure that this is being offered up as "proof" Peter, perhaps it is a side of the story to counter the State version. Which version to believe? Of course none in there entirety...but because of the blocking of journalism from the country (which I don't know for a fact of course, because we only learn things in two ways...from experience and from an account from another). In any event..quit pouting, Peter and others, and let people have their say...especially the citizens of Iran.
peter etc: of course the author is exaggerating and of course this is not an "objective" view if that were possible under these circumstances. this a euphoric report from the heart of a social movement in a moment of efflorescence. as such i at least found it extremely interesting, not least because of this confidence that they represent "all of iran"
Great writing depicting the true nature of Dictatorship in today's Iran and the way a bunch of so called Islamists actually treat the free thinking masses of Iran.These Mullhas and Ayatolahs, under the disguise of so called "Islam and religion", have been torturing and suppressing the nation of Iran for the past 30 years.But now, People of Iran have seen their true face and criminal identity. They are no longer fooled by the outer garments of Religiosity they wear.This is not just about Mousavi, this is about a revolution based on the freedom of thought, speech, ideologies, and all that true democracy entails. People of Iran have spoken unanimously and most vehemently against the tyranny of the so called Islamic Republic and will not stop till these Mullahs and their fanatic supporters- mostly paid agents-are overthrown for once and for all. Thanks a million Professor Cole for daring to tell the truth.
"I can't help myself, the idea for an Al Gore-Mir Hossein Mousavi buddy film pops into my mind, "Dude, Where is My Vote?"
A few questions, Professor:
How many mass protests occurred after the 2000 election? How many hundreds of 1000s of people marched on Washington DC?
How many people were killed in the protests that followed the 2000 election?
What autocratic government body gave President Bush over 60% of the vote in 2000?*
How many universities were shut down? For how long were the Internet and cell phones disabled? How many people arrested?
Is there really a comparison, professor, or is it just fun to pretend you live in an autocratic theocracy where your vote doesn't really count?
Do you really think that it is appropriate to joke about a situation in which at several people have died for their beliefs?
A "Dude, Where's My Car?" buddy film comparison? People have lost their lives....
At least your students will kiss your ....
*in anticipation an ad homimen attack if I allowed this to go without clarification, I know Bush got under 50% of the vote.
Seems the hardliner quarter of the US runs to support the hardliner quarter of Iran (looking at Steve, Peter and Lidia). Or is it Iranian counterintelligence speaking here? It is hard to believe you have sincere comments. There are many reports including video coming out of Iran, and they fit quite closely to this story. Andrew Sullivans blog has video of the shooting at a Basiji base on Monday, and their snipers seem to have fired first, before the crowd threw anything. Many videos from Saturday and Sunday show police hitting people brutally, I remember a closeup from a bruised back that obviously had made contact with police batons. Considering that there are hundreds of thousands of people demonstrating in Tehran alone each day, they have been amazingly peaceful overall. Robert Fisk is in Tehran reporting from the demonstrations (he writes for the Independent) and he reports rather similar stories.
"This author has no need to report the story from the view of the Republican Guard. Any militia, policeman, soldier, etc. who would fire upon their own countryman in support of a person such as Ahmadinejad, deserves to be killed."
using that logic its perfectly acceptable to kill Mousavi since he had no qualms about killing his fellow countrymen when he was in iranian politics 20 years ago. the same goes for his fellow "reformers" whose reign of terror in the 90's seems to have fallen down the memory hole in this part of the internet.
If this correspondent did not grow up with English as the quality of her or his writing suggests, s/he is a very talented linguist indeed.
Those in power will go to extremes to keep it, their words can not be trusted. The best truth we can distill from this situation is to listen to the voices of Iranians around the world, and the brave men and women in Iran fighting and dying for their freedom. That's the only real truth, and it will prevail.
Post a Comment
<< Home