Syria crisis Shakes Lebanon, Iraq, Saudi Arabia as Cease-Fire Crumbles

The inability of the Syrian government to crush an 18-month-old revolutionary movement is putting increasing pressure on its neighbors. Not only have hundreds of thousands of refugees from Syria poured into Jordan, Turkey, Lebanon and Iraq, but political forces in each of those countries are having to choose sides and to reevaluate their choices over time.

In Saudi Arabia on Sunday, hundreds of Syrian pilgrims in Mecca staged a protest against the Damascus government. They were quickly dispersed by Saudi security forces, who do not permit political manifestations during the Hajj on pilgrimage.

The bombing in Beirut’s Ashrafieh neighborhood that killed security chief Wissam al-Hassan last week has widely been blamed inside Lebanon on the Shiite Hizbullah party-militia, which backs the current government of Najib al-Miqati. Angry Lebanese Sunnis of the March 14 movement led by Saad al-Hariri, who oppose the government of Bashar al-Assad in Syria and sympathize with their Sunni co-religionists in the Syrian opposition, have vowed to bring down the Miqati government. Miqati said Sunday that although he had thought about resigning, he has decided not to stand down.

Still, it remains to be seen if the Lebanese government can avoid falling, given the firestorm set off by the Syria conflict. The problem for Miqati and Hizbullah is that among their key coalition partners is Walid Jumblatt, the mercurial Druze leader, who is said to be turning against the Baath government of Syria. (Jumblatt has flip-flopped on Baathist Syria several times; it is alleged that Bashar al-Assad’s father, Hafez al-Assad, had Walid’s father, Kamal Jumblatt, assassinated in 1977.) The Washington Post is even hinting that Hizbullah’s Hassan Nasrullah is himself wavering on whether to continue to support Syria so strongly, given the possibility that it could mean the loss of the Miqati government and the political marginalization of Hizbullah inside Lebanon. I actually doubt that Hizbullah is wavering, given its strong alliance with Iran, which is backing al-Assad.

(Although Iran is allied with Syria, it is not true, as Mitt Romney alleged, that Iran is Syria’s neighbor, nor that Syria is ‘Iran’s route to the sea’.)

Likewise, the Syria conflict is spilling over onto Iraq, where the NYT alleges some Shiite fighters are going to Damascus to defend the shrine of Sayyida Zainab, holy to their branch of Islam, from possible destruction by hard line Salafis that have already targeted that neighborhood. During the Iraq War, hundreds of thousands of Iraqis fled to Syria, and Shiite Iraqis congregated around the shrine. They have largely been ethnically cleansed by hard line Sunnis, seen as foreigners supporting the al-Assad regime, and there are concerns that Wahhabi-influenced Salafis might raze the shrine. (Saudi Wahhabis, like early militant Protestants in 16th-century Europe, are iconoclasts who despise the cult of saints, shrines and relics, insisting that only God is holy, and no intercession is possible with Him by third parties. Shiite Muslims, in contrast, are all about saints related to the Prophet Muhammad, and their tombs and shrines, and do believe they will intercede for believers.)

On Saturday, Sunni guerrillas unleashed a series of bombings and attacks on Shiite pilgrims and Shiite neighborhoods in Iraq. Although this tactic of attempting to foment Sunni-Shiite violence is by now 9 years old, it may be continuing in force in part because of the new struggle over the future of Syria. Syria’s Baath government is secular, socialist and nationalist, but the upper echelons of the Baath government and army are dominated by members of the Alawite minority, a form of folk Shiism. About 10-14 percent of Syrians are Alawite. The al-Assad government also has a geopolitical alliance with Shiite Iran and, increasingly, the Shiite government of Iraq.

The idea of a 4-day cease-fire in Syria’s ongoing revolution/ civil war during the Eid al-Adha (Feast of Sacrifice, commemorating Abraham’s willingness to sacrifice his son for God) was always a difficult proposition. Cease-fires work when two sides are exhausted and can’t see how easily to make further gains through fighting. That situation does not obtain in Syria– the ceaseless back-and-forth of guerrilla strikes and regime reprisal has been going on for over a year, and the revolutionaries appear to have gradually chipped away at the Baath government’s control of much of the country. When one side has the momentum, it simply makes no sense to have a cease-fire.

On Friday, the very first day of the attempted cease-fire, a massive truck bomb shook the capital, blamed on a radical fundamentalist group that has, however, denied involvement. The regime accuses the revolutionaries of using it as a cover to try to take more territory, while the rebels accuse the regime of launching aerial bombings and artillery barrages designed to roll back their positions in Homs and the Damascus suburbs.

Aljazeera English has video

As the Syrian revolution continues to unfold, it is likely to reshape not only Syrian politics but also those of its neighbors.

4 Responses

  1. On the anti-Shiite bombings in Iraq: is it your impression that this mainly an Iraqi Sunni phenomenon, and not primarily the work of foreign jihadists (as the similar bombings circa 2005 were?)

    Or perhaps it would be better to ask, do you see them as more Iraqi Sunni than those during the American occupation? Since there are clearly elements of both at work in both situations.

    Do you think al Qaeda is still working to foment a sectarian civil war in Iraq?

  2. Dear Professor Cole

    “there are concerns that Wahhabi-influenced Salafis might raze the shrine. (of Sayyida Zainab)

    “Hassan al-Rubaie, a Shiite cleric from Baquba, the capital of Diyala Province, said, “The destruction of the shrine of Sayyida Zeinab in Syria will mean the start of sectarian civil war in Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Bahrain and Saudi Arabia.”

    For those unfamiliar with the shrine it is an extraordinarily beuatiful complex of buildings, made even more so by its contrast with the ugly bus garage next door.

    It is quite clear that destroying the shrine of the Prophet’s Grandaughter would be a sacrilege of an order coming close to the destruction of Haram al Sharif by fundamentalist Jews.

    It remains to be seen if this might be the spark that would trigger insurrection by the Shia in Saudi Arabia.

    It is time for Western Governments to think seriously about how to get the Salafi Warrior Genie back in the bottle.

    The prospect of serious instability in Saudi Arabia as a result of the actions of some misguided idiot with a truck bomb in Damascus followed by a general exchange of hostilities throughout the former Turkish Empire can only fill us with trepidation.

    The antics of the Wild Card in Jerusalem where the corrupt Lithuanian thug has been offered his choice of ministries of Foreign Affairs, Defence or Finance can only increase the perception that widespread shooting is about to break out.

    It starts to feel like June 1914.

    • It is time for Western Governments to think seriously about how to get the Salafi Warrior Genie back in the bottle.

      1. What makes you think that they could?

      2. What makes you think they haven’t been trying?

Comments are closed.