Uncle Sam’s Eternal Gua-Gulag: US Continues to Imprison Dozens of Yemenis Cleared or Never Charged

(Human Rights Watch)

(Washington, DC) – The US should expedite the return of Yemeni detainees cleared for release from Guantanamo Bay, Human Rights Watch said today in a letter to President Barack Obama. Human Rights Watch released a video showing the plight of families of Yemeni detainees. All Guantanamo detainees should be returned or resettled, or charged and prosecuted in US federal courts.

Obama imposed a moratorium on returning Guantanamo detainees to Yemen after the arrest of the “Christmas Day bomber,” who had trained in the country. Although he lifted the moratorium in May 2013, no Yemeni has been returned, and currently 56 of the 76 Guantanamo detainees recommended for transfer are Yemeni.

“President Obama lifted his moratorium on returns to Yemen nearly a year ago, yet the Yemenis OK’d for release remained trapped in Guantanamo largely because of their nationality,” said Andrea Prasow, senior national security counsel at Human Rights Watch. “If the president truly intends to close Guantanamo, he needs to repatriate the Yemenis, some of whom were cleared more than four years ago.”

On his second full day in office, Obama pledged to close the Guantanamo detention center, and reiterated that commitment in his 2014 State of the Union address. Yet 154 men remain in Guantanamo, including 88 Yemenis. The return of Yemeni detainees, most of whom have never been charged, is an essential component of any plan to close the detention facility, Human Rights Watch said.

The long-time detention of individuals without charge or trial, and thus an indeterminate imprisonment, creates hardships for their families, Human Rights Watch said. Abdulqadir Idris, a Yemeni whose brother was recommended for transfer from Guantanamo four years ago, told Human Rights Watch: “If they don’t release him now, when do they plan to release him? … He is in prison, but we don’t know if he’s been sent to trial. Is he guilty, not guilty?”

Aziz Ahmed al-Methali, the father of a Yemeni detainee who has been neither charged nor cleared for release, said: “When he was first detained, we expected him to be there a month, maybe a year. We still believed in the fair and just systems of the US. But when it went on 13 years, I understood that they lack a sense of humanity. They have no mercy. They can’t discriminate between the innocent and the criminal.”

The vast majority of detainees at Guantanamo are being held in prolonged indefinite detention without charge or trial, in violation of international human rights law. Alleged mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and four others implicated in the September 11, 2001 attacks, as well as a Saudi national charged with the 2000 attack on the USS Cole, are being tried before the fundamentally flawed military commissions at Guantanamo. Human Rights Watch has long called on the United States to either prosecute detainees in trials that meet international due process standards, or release them.

“Unlawfully detaining people for years unjustly punishes them and their families,” Prasow said. “Repatriating men to Yemen who were recommended for return years ago is an essential step towards rejecting indefinite detention without charge.”

Mirrored from Human Rights Watch

One response

  1. Two points I’d like to make:

    President Obama believes that he is powerless to send Gitmo Detainees elsewhere, wholesale. He will never close the place down.
    In April, 2009, 3 months after his advisor Greg Craig had persuaded Obama to announce closure of Gitmo within 1 year, his Chief of Staff Emmanuel told him not to, or he would not get reelected.
    The calculation is that one of the “Cleared for Release” Prisoners could, after release, commit some sort of crime. If that happened, any politician who didn’t do all he could to keep the guy locked up, even though he is technically functionally innocent, would be punished by voters in the next election.
    If Obama was to approve a mass release or resettlement or repatriation, and if any one of those released did something wrong, then his party would be held accountable and lose elections for one or more cycles. To some politicians, that’s a bigger deal than following the rule of law.
    The Detainees’ best hope for release is for Rand Paul to be elected President. He at least supports the Constitution and the rule of law. Not likely to happen.

    2. GUANTANAMO CZARS at DOD and State already have a plan of action for Closure
    Special Envoys Sloan and Lewis have a plan that will allow the complete closure of the place, if that was what the administration wanted. It’s called the Dat-dazh-deet deradicalization program, in some circles.
    Why not execute it ? See Point #1.
    They are still free to resettle prisoners case-by-case to allies, in exchange for one type of aid or another. Palau, for example, got a $ 200 Million + facility through the IMF in exchange for agreeing to “temporarily resettle” 17 Uighurs (they eventually took in 7.) Bermuda and El Salvador got about half that much per prisoner to take in 4 and 2, respectively.
    It’s thought that Albania takes them in at cost, as did Algeria.
    But there will be no mass transfer.

Comments are closed.