Dear Hillary Clinton: When did not bombing Syria create Isis?

By Fariborz S Fatemi

Hillary Clinton’s criticism of Barack Obama on Syria and the rise of Isis is wrong, and an exercise in selective memory. When did not bombing Syria create ISIS? In her interview with The Atlantic magazine, the former secretary of state fails to point out that the president wanted to bomb Syria but was prevented from doing so by Congress, which did not authorise it.

Furthermore, by not bombing and with the use of wise diplomacy, the president successfully brought the chemical weapons out of Syria. Furthermore, is it credible that bombing Syria and arming the “invisible” moderates would have made a difference? Contrary to Mrs Clinton’s comments, they were armed.

If past and present events are any guide, most of the weapons given to the opponents of President Bashar al-Assad (during her tenure) have fallen into the hands of the most extremist elements of that opposition. Could it be that our premier diplomat did not learn that diplomacy is the best way forward?

“Peace, progress and prosperity” is a slogan and not an organising principle. And yes, after eight years of Bush/Cheney foreign policy, “not doing stupid things” is an organising principle.

Fariborz S Fatemi, McLean, VA, US Former Professional Staff Member, House Foreign Affairs Committee, Senate Foreign Relations Committee

This piece originally appeared as a letter to the editor in The Financial Times.


Related video added by Juan Cole

The Young Turks: “Hillary Clinton Criticizes Obama’s Foreign Policy With Neocon Talking Points”

One response

  1. please don’t give the credit for not bombing Syria to the US Congress. Those warmongers never met a war they didn’t approve of. Doesn’t anyone remember Putin’s pivotal role in thwarting what would have been yet another disastrous American invasion of a Mulsim country? Russian proposals to secure the handover of Syria’s chemical weapons before key talks in Geneva are what convinced Obama not to bomb. The US Congress simply agreed.

Comments are closed.