From Beirut, this is Paris: in a world that doesn’t care about Arab lives

Elie Fares | (Open Democracy) | – –

There is a stark contrast in the reaction of the world to the horrific terrorist attacks in Lebanon and France. But in the world that doesn’t care about Arab lives, Arabs lead the way.

When a friend told me past midnight to check the news about Paris, I had no idea that I would be looking at a map of a city I love, delineating locations undergoing terrorist attacks simultaneously. I zoomed in on that map closer; one of the locations was right next to where I had stayed when I was there in 2013, down that same boulevard.

The more I read, the higher the number of fatalities rose. It was horrible; it was dehumanizing; it was utterly and irrevocably hopeless: 2015 was ending the way it had started—with terrorist attacks occuring in Lebanon and France almost at the same time, in the same context of demented creatures spreading hate and fear and death wherever they went.

I woke up this morning to two broken cities. My friends in Paris, who only yesterday were asking what was happening in Beirut, were now on the opposite side of the line. Both our capitals were broken and scarred, old news to us perhaps but foreign territory to them.

Today, 128 innocent civilians in Paris are no longer with us. Yesterday, 45 innocent civilians in Beirut were no longer with us. The death tolls keep rising, but we never seem to learn.

When my people were blown to pieces, the headlines read: explosion in Hezbollah stronghold.

Amid the chaos and tragedy of it all, one nagging thought wouldn’t leave my head. It’s the same thought that echoes inside my skull at every single one of these events, which are becoming sadly very recurrent: we don’t really matter.

When my people were blown to pieces on the streets of Beirut on 12 November, the headlines read: explosion in Hezbollah stronghold, as if delineating the political background of a heavily urban area somehow placed the terrorism in context.

When my people died on the streets of Beirut on 12 November, world leaders did not rise in condemnation. There were no statements expressing sympathy with the Lebanese people. There was no global outrage that innocent people whose only fault was being at the wrong place the wrong time should never have to go that way, or that their families should be broken that way, or that someone’s sect or political background should be a hyphen before feeling horrified at how their corpses burned on cement. Obama did not issue a statement about how their death was a crime against humanity; after all, what is humanity but a subjective term delineating the worth of the human being?

What happened instead was an American senator wannabe proclaiming how happy he was that my people died, that my country’s capital was being shattered, that innocents were losing their lives and that the casualties included people of all kinds of kinds.

Image: Elie Feras. All rights reserved.When my people died, no country bothered to light up its landmarks in the colors of our flag. Even Facebook didn’t bother with making sure my people were “marked safe”, trivial as it may be. So here’s your Facebook safety check: we’ve, as of now, survived all of Beirut’s terrorist attacks.

When my people died, the world was not in mourning. Their death was but an irrelevant fleck on the international news cycle, something that happens in those parts of the world.

And you know what, I’m fine with all of it. Over the past year or so, I’ve come to terms with being one of those whose lives don’t matter. I’ve come to accept it and live with it.

Expect the next few days to exhibit yet another rise of Islamophobia around the world. Expect pieces about how extremism has no religion and how members of ISIS are not true Muslims, which they definitely are not, because no person with any inkling of morality would do such things. ISIS is obviously planning for Islamophobic backlash, so it can use it to point its hellish finger and tell any susceptible mind that listens: look, they hate you.

And few are those who are able to rise above.

We can ask for the world to think Beirut is as important as Paris, but the truth is, we are a people that doesn’t care about itself to begin with.

Expect the next few days to have Europe try and cope with a growing popular backlash against the refugees flowing into its lands, pointing its fingers and accusing them of causing the night of 13 November in Paris. If only Europe knew, though, that the night of 13 November in Paris has been every single night of the life of those refugees for the past two years. But sleepless nights only matter when your country can get the whole world to light up in its flag colors.

The more horrifying part of the reaction to the Paris terrorist attacks, however, is that some Arabs and Lebanese were more saddened by what was taking place there than by what took place yesterday or the day before in their own backyards. Even among my people, there is a sense that we are not as important, that our lives are not as worthy and that, even as little as it may be, we do not deserve to have our dead collectively mourned and prayed for.

It makes sense, perhaps, in the grand sense of a Lebanese population that’s more likely to visit Paris than Dahyeh to care more about the former than about the latter, but many of the people I know who are utterly devastated by the Parisian mayhem couldn’t give a rat’s ass about what took place at a location 15 minutes away from where they live, to people they probably encountered one day as they walked down familiar streets.

We can ask for the world to think Beirut is as important as Paris, or for Facebook to add a “safety check” button for us to use daily, or for people to care about us. But the truth of the matter is, we are a people that doesn’t care about itself to begin with. We call it habituation, but it’s really not. We call it the new normal, but if this is normality then let it go to hell.

In the world that doesn’t care about Arab lives, Arabs are on the front lines.

First published on A Separate State of Mind on 14 November 2015.

Via Open Democracy


Related video added by Juan Cole:

France 24: “Beirut bombings: “concerns that ISIS is infiltrating Palestinian and Syrian camps to recruit”

8 Responses

  1. It is not true that people in the West (so-called) don’t care what is happening to all innocent lives in these conflicts. It is horrific wherever this murder occurs. It maybe that with our greater electronic communications we have more global media outlets (and more freedoms). i would like to say that your people and ours are suffering terrible evil acts, and I deeply feel for all affected, and hope we can unite in peace and tolerance to defeat this madness.

  2. I care.
    I care and my heart shatters every time I hear of a bomb In Beirut, or shootings in Kenya, or bulldozers in Palestine.
    I care but I am an unemployed carpenter and mom and I don’t know what to do. If I could stop a bomb or a bulldozer I would do it. I would stand before tanks to save moms and dads and children. I would trade my life for peace for you. If I could give my life, that the horror and destruction could stop, stop finally I would. If I could share my canadian wilderness peace with you, I would.

  3. Excellent article! The bias in the press in the West is really appalling. Attacks with innocent victims in the West are invariably followed by in depth journalism of the pain felt by family, friends and by-standers, lofty statements by politicians, on how right the west is and how looney the attackers are etc., etc. Innocent victims in the Middle East are dealt with with three or four lines on page two in the papers, and a 15 second item on the TV, the idea being that they’re simply all crazy back there. Sometimes even the attack is reported as a funny event: “Bride and Boom” (hahaha, great joke) in stead of bride and groom, when yet another marriage is mistaken for a terrorst gathering.

    I feel deeply ashamed

    • It’s not just about CNN, you know. Obama apparently “forgot” about the Beirut bombing. Read :

      “Obama did not issue a statement about how their death was a crime against humanity; after all, what is humanity but a subjective term delineating the worth of the human being?”

  4. Hi Dorothy,

    Please do an objective survey of the amount of coverage Paris got and its tone against:

    1. the coverage the blown up Russian airline (full of families on vacation) received (lots of coverage but mostly schadenfreude, including from the US Secretary of Defence.
    2. the coverage Lebanon received (almost none).

    In any case, Juan didn’t write this article but Elie Fares. Bravo to him for publishing it.

    We owe ourselves a great deal of soul seeking why we consider some human lives and some races/nationalities worthy of compassion and others not.

Comments are closed.