Syria: al-Qaeda, Army of Islam Cage Hostages in Street as Human Shields

Human Rights Watch | – –

(New York) – Syrian armed groups are endangering civilians, including women, and detaining soldiers by placing them in metal cages throughout Eastern Ghouta. The armed groups say they are doing that to deter indiscriminate government attacks on the area.

Still from video showing caged civilians in Eastern Ghouta, Syria. Courtesy of Sham News Network Youtube.

The use of detained soldiers and civilians in this manner illegally puts them at grave risk of harm, Human Rights Watch said. The practice constitutes hostage-taking and an outrage against their personal dignity, which are both war crimes.

“Nothing can justify caging people and intentionally putting them in harm’s way, even if the purpose is to stop indiscriminate government attacks,” said Nadim Houry, deputy Middle East director. “Ending Syria’s downward spiral requires international backers of armed groups as well as the government to make protecting civilians a top priority.”

Nothing can justify caging people and intentionally putting them in harm’s way, even if the purpose is to stop indiscriminate government attacks. Ending Syria’s downward spiral requires international backers of armed groups as well as the government to make protecting civilians a top priority.

Nadim Houry

Deputy Middle East Director

A video posted on November 1, 2015, by the Shaam News Network, a local opposition outlet, shows trucks transporting cages, each containing between four to eight men or women.

The accompanying text states, “Rebels in Ghouta have distributed 100 cages, with each cage containing approximately seven people and the plan is afoot to produce 1,000 cages to distribute in Eastern Ghouta … in different parts of Douma city particularly in public places and markets that have been attacked in the past by the regime and Russian air-force.” The footage includes interviews with a detained colonel and two Alawite women being held in metal cages.

The largest armed group in Eastern Ghoutta is Jaysh al-Islam, headed by Zahran Alloush. While the group has not claimed responsibility for this decision, the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights accused Jaysh al-Islam of responsibility for the action. In the course of fighting between armed groups and government forces in the nearby `Adra al-`Omalia in December 2013, Jabhat al-Nusra and Jaysh al-Islam abducted hundreds of civilians, mostly Alawites, according to the United Nations Commission of Inquiry on Syria. The hostages, many of them women and children, are being held in unidentified locations in Eastern Ghouta. The concern is that they are among those in these cages.

Syrian government forces have repeatedly attacked residential areas and popular markets in Eastern Ghouta, where an estimated 150,000 civilians still live. On October 30, government attacks on a marketplace in Douma, the largest town in Eastern Ghouta, killed at least 70 people and wounded 550, according to Doctors Without Borders (MSF). On August 16, government air attacks on Douma’s popular markets and residential areas killed at least 112 people, whom witnesses and first responders said were overwhelmingly civilian. The consequences of these attacks has been made worse by the siege government forces have imposed on Eastern Ghouta, limiting access to food, clean water, and medical care.

The Shaam video includes interviews with local residents who justify the use of the cages by arguing that this may deter further attacks. “Your women are our women,” a teenage boy standing near one of the cages is filmed as saying. “If you want to kill my mother, you will kill them too.”

On October 30, the day of the government attacks on Douma that killed a reported 70 people, key regional and international actors on Syria met in Vienna to discuss the conflict. They issued a nine-point statement agreeing on some issues but failing to agree on immediate measures to stop indiscriminate attacks.

In situations of armed conflict in which international humanitarian law applies, hostage-taking is considered a war crime. This is defined as detaining people, and then threatening them to compel a third party to carry out or abstain from specific acts as an explicit or implicit condition for the hostages’ release or safety.

International humanitarian law also bans outrages upon personal dignity, which are defined in the Elements of Crimes for the International Criminal Court as acts that humiliate, degrade, or otherwise violate the dignity of a person to such a degree “as to be generally recognized as an outrage upon personal dignity.”

“Human shielding” is also prohibited in international law. The Geneva Conventions and the statute of the International Criminal Court couch the prohibition against using human shields in terms of using the presence of civilians or other protected people, such as detained fighters, to make certain points, areas, or military forces immune from military operations. State practice establishes this rule as a norm of customary international law, applicable in both international and non-international armed conflicts.

This is the second reported instance in Syria of placing detainees in cages to use them to attempt to deter attacks. On September 13, a Facebook page used to spread local news from Fu`a and Kefraya, two Shia towns in Idlib besieged by Jaysh al-Fateh, a coalition of opposition armed groups including Ahrar al-Sham and Jabhat al-Nusra, posted images of a cage that they claimed contained detained Jaysh al-Fateh combatants that had been placed on top of a building in the besieged communities by fighters defending the towns. Their stated aim was reportedly to deter indiscriminate shelling by Jaysh al-Fateh.

“Syrians get no protection from mere statements at international conferences,” Houry said. “The path forward for international and regional players should include concrete measures to force the warring parties to release thousands of unlawfully detained people and to stop indiscriminate attacks.”

Via Human Rights Watch


Related video added by Juan Cole:

CCTV News: “Syrian rebels lock people in cages as human shields”

3 Responses

  1. ملطشة

    alqaeda means the base, but a more apt name is the debased.
    And the other should be called the army of inhumanity.

  2. This is nothing compared to the violent rape by multiple “…….” Jaish Al-Islam men or what so called “Jaish-Al-Hurr”, as the young woman in this video called them, of any pro government woman they can get their hands on. There is no word in the dictionary to describe these monsters. They are not even worthy of the word men because they are not even humans. Not just in cages, they literally have women and children slaves that they sell after finishing with them. But this video in particular, that they obviously wanted to be published, they are being so unbelievably stupid. In this video, the young woman calling herself Alawite coming all the way from the village of Kirdaha, the Assad’s family’s hometown, doesn’t even have the accent they are so famously known for.
    This video is not meant to address or threaten the Syrian government in order for it to stop bombing, hence the as we speak Russian’s bombs over the east Goutha. If all detained women in their hands are actually being treated like this and being able to look this way and speak with such a confident loud voice, even in paraded cages, then we are seeing Jaish Al-Islam or what this woman called them Al-Jaish Al-Hurr, then we are seeing their Heaven. Their hell is not depicted in this video. The barbarism being committed by these militants, one can argue, make any atrocities committed by what’s called “Shabihah”, the Syrian security forces, dwarf in comparison. No wonder the vast majority of Syrian civilians chose to live under government protected areas when ever they can flee.
    These cages are just a drop in their bloody filled hands.
    May God help Syrians during this holocaust ( please no one comment to tell me I shouldn’t use that word, it’s anti Semitic to compare, and offensive to Jews). I am a Semite. Even Jews in their concentration camps didn’t experience barbaric violence on this level. These atrocities being committed against Syrians and financed by non Syrians, Yes, NON Syrians, is a genocide with every meaning of the word. Shame on these governments, they will have their names carved in history way above Hitler’s name. And what is the so called international community doing.. Yes, keep nudging Saudis Al-Jubeir’s arm for a photo Shute while laughing, like what our John Kerry did, his partner he called him.

Comments are closed.