The Saudi-Russian Oil Price Freeze is about Power, not Money

By Nafis Alam | (The Conversation) | – –

Saudi Arabia and Russia, the world’s two most powerful oil producers, have reached a tentative agreement to freeze oil production at its current levels. As the first deal between an OPEC and non-OPEC member in 15 years, it marks a significant declaration of intent. But it is not geared toward buoying oil prices, as some might hope. Rather, it has much more to do with blocking Iran’s re-emergence as a global oil exporter.

The agreement between the two countries to keep output at January levels led to much noise of a market rally, with little to show in the way of gains. The benchmark price of Brent crude jumped briefly from US$33.4 to US$35.55 a barrel but it will not lead to a sustained rise in prices.

For starters, the agreement is not a cut in production levels. In January, Saudi production was sky high; significantly up from December. So the announcement of the freeze in production was part of a strategy to merely stabilise prices.

Geopolitics at play

The story is about much more than just prices. The current state of play is that both Russia and Saudi Arabia, the number one and two oil suppliers, respectively, are trying to stop Iran from making any further inroads into the global oil market.

Saudi Arabia has always been at loggerheads with Iran when it comes to oil production – and everything else besides. It is aware that oil prices will fall further when sanctions on Iran are completely lifted. By acting now, it is hoping to pressure other major producers to follow suit, and that Iran will fall into line with the other members of OPEC.

Another concern for Saudi Arabia is losing its position as the main strategic partner of the US to Iran, especially after failing to dissuade the US from removing economic sanctions against Iran for its nuclear program. It is hoping to put Iran in its place by limiting the gains it can make from the uplift in economic sanctions.

It is difficult to understand the reasoning behind the Saudi-Russia friendship. They are, after all, the two biggest oil producing rivals who are now presenting a united front on oil supply. They are also backing opposite sides in the Syrian civil war, all the while trying to convince the world that they share a common cause in stopping the global oil market rout.

But the 70% drop in oil prices has hit the economies of both countries hard. Saudi Arabia is running a budget deficit close to more than 15% of national income and burning through its cash reserves to plug the gap in oil revenues. Russia too is expanding its deficit to cover its costs.

The shared pressure seems to have brought the two rivals together. The Saudi Arabian promise to curtail production is part of a strategy with the US to pressure Russia to drop its support for Bashar al-Assad, the Syrian president, at a time when the Russian government is suffering from the effects of low prices.

“If oil can serve to bring peace in Syria, I don’t see how Saudi Arabia would back away from trying to reach a deal”, a Saudi diplomat told the New York Times.

Persistent production

It is evident that the output freeze could bring stability to the market, but it will not lower record high oil supplies. The only thing that is certain is the suffering of high cost producers, including the US shale industry, which is set to continue.

Markets have been rightly sceptical of Saudi Arabia and Russia’s announcement of a production freeze. Although Iran welcomed the deal, it has made no promise of curtailing its production. And when it comes to OPEC’s commitment to a production freeze, the potential for “quota cheating” (where struggling members overproduce to increase revenues) is as high as ever.

How long we can trust the Saudi-Russia deal to last is open to question too. While Russia and Saudi Arabia appear to have put aside their differences for the time being, their longstanding mutual distrust could well change things. Russia has always shunned OPEC, the Saudi-led oil exporters cartel and historically resisted any binding coordination with it to bolster global oil prices. There is little reason to expect a real change of heart.

So the output freeze may stabilise the market for the time being and send a clear message to Iran that there is still a long way for it to regain back its economic glory. But it is a long way from ensuring the struggling economies of oil producing countries survive the biggest crisis in the global oil market.

The Conversation

Nafis Alam, Associate Professor of Finance, Director- Centre for Islamic Business and Finance Research (CIBFR), University of Nottingham

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.


Related video added by Juan Cole:

RT: “Russia, Saudi Arabia agree to freeze oil production”

5 Responses

  1. It is hard to believe that “Russia and Saudi Arabia…are trying to stop Iran … inroads into the global oil market” while Iran is the major player with Russia in Syria. More likely Russia and Iran have agreed to this non-limit of production so as to head off a Saudi invasion of Syria, or simply for mutual gain.

    The writer does not support his hypothesis of a Russia-Iran divide, so one is left suspecting political bias.

  2. This is another meaningless market agreement.

    Saudi Arabia is (literally) burning their future. While the demand for oil is going to decrease over time due to non-carbon energy increases, the oil supply will also decrease over time due to excessive pumping. By selling “cheap” oil today, KSA is literally selling their future for no real political gain.

    Iran’s actual production costs are as low as KSA’s and because Iran has not been selling very much oil and what oil they did sell, was sold at very deep discounts from the world prices, their fiscal policies are much more frugal than KSA’s. Basically, unless the selling price of oil approaches zero (not likely), every dollar Iran makes is just added revenue.

    Basically, KSA is shooting itself in the foot out of political spite and their actions will backfire.

    It is LOOOOOONG past time for the leaders of KSA to grow up and be responsible global citizens. They need to get over their ego problems and do what is best for the world (and ALL their own citizens).

  3. I am sorry but this article doesn’t make much sense, at least given the premise that Russia and Saudi Arabia are making some power play. To preserve market share you don’t freeze production. You increase it, which is exactly what the Saudis did in response to the increase in US and Canadian shale oil production. And the oil price decrease is actually much more complicated than just the Saudis pumping like crazy. Reduced demand, cost of sustainable energy sources going down (sustainable energy sources like solar are actually cheaper now to build than drilling), and over supply in other areas all play a part. Also missing in this analysis is the the fact that the agreement requires the participation of other major suppliers, including Iran. And the Iranian oil minister actually did make a positive statement about participating. So unless I missed something some where I don’t see how this is some collusion against Iran specifically, particularly given the very recent thawing of Russian-Iranian relations. For instance in December they started discussing a major currency agreement that could significantly impact the dollar.

  4. No matter what the Saudis and the Russians do, won’t Iranian oil production, plus the newly-allowed exports from the U.S., still increase global supply and thus drive down prices?

  5. At least it’s the first sign that Saudi Arabia and Russia don’t want to continue their march towards war with each other in Syria. That doesn’t mean it still can’t happen, but they’re not rushing joyously into it.

Comments are closed.