Iran’s Khamenei: Trump Unbalanced, Playing Crazy Games, but Iran policy will Fail

By Juan Cole | (Informed Comment) | – –

Iran’s clerical leader, Ali Khamenei, gave a speech in Qom on Tuesday, in which he warned Donald Trump that his “crazy games” would not go without a response. Western news outlets such as the NYT tried to represent this speech as a threat, and some outlets translated “crazy” as “psychotic” in search of hyperbole. As usual, if an unfriendly government warns Washington not to interfere in its affairs, that is interpreted as an aggressive threat against Washington.

Iran is awaiting a decision from the Trump administration on sanctions that could destroy the JCPOA or nuclear deal. American hardliners have called for ratcheting up sanctions on Iran, instead of, as the deal requires, reducing them.

Khamenei said that recent events were the result of the anger and sense of defeat among American officials. He denied that the Iranian government was panicked, and noted that it had been cool-headed enough to kick the US out of Iran and then more recently to kick it out of the Middle East.

He said that the American leader (Trump) is admitted by the Americans themselves to be unbalanced psychologically, and warned that his crazy games would not go without a reply. He said that if the US again tried to interfere in Iran, it would fail again.

He also said Americans had no standing to criticize Iran for repressing violent protests, given that US police killed 800 people last year. (Actually many of the protests in Iran were not violent, and actually two wrongs don’t make a right).

Over twenty Iranian protesters were killed in the past few weeks and hundreds or perhaps thousands were arrested.

Khamenei said that the US analysis of Iran as an oppressive government is wrong and that the Islamic Republic derives from the people of Iran themselves. (If he is now admitting the principle of poplar sovereignty, then he should stop excluding liberal candidates from running and let the people decide).

He dismissed the violent protesters in recent weeks as saboteurs and tools of the devil and foreign agents, speaking of a conflict between the “nation” and the “anti-nation,” “Iran” and “anti-Iran,” and “Islam” and “anti-Islam,” which he said was destined to continue. It is striking how close this diction is to that of ancient Zoroastrian Iran, where people spoke of Iran and non-Iran in a dualistic way. He blamed the United States and the UK for their steadfast opposition to the Islamic Republic and ridiculed counter-revolutionary Iranians resident in London.

Despite beginning with this dismissive tone, he took a leaf from elected President Hassan Rouhani’s book, going on to say that a firm distinction must be made between the legitimate demands of peaceful protesters and the mindless destruction of others, and that the demands of the former must be taken seriously. It was a small (very small) olive branch to the protesters from the head of the hard line faction.

He accused the more hooligan-like protesters of cursing Islam and the Qur’an and of burning the Iranian flag. You wonder if he’s giving away more than he realizes.

He blamed the protests on 1) the US and Israel, 2) Saudi Arabia, and ) the Mojahedin-e Khalq or MEK cult, which has cooperated with Saddam Hussein and the American right wing in hopes of overthrowing the current government and implementing their vision of “Islamic Marxism.”

Needless to say, crowds protesting the price of eggs in Quchan had nothing to do with any of these, and Khamenei is just slandering the protesters.


Related video:

Al Jazeera English: “Iran’s supreme leader vows ‘response’ for unrest”

3 Responses

  1. Your voice is so valuable. Will there be, can there be a mainstream media outlet that can even come close to what you’re providing for all of us truth-seekers.

    I was moved by the letter sent out last fall to previous contributors and the eloquence of your argument in favor of small donations. I hope I understand how you are personally opposed to pumping yourself like the 99% of the bad internet, yet I would encourage you to share that argument with your general readership to help reach your goal.

  2. It’s reassuring to read the unique perspective offered here, since it doesn’t leave any side off the hook.
    As far as Khamenei himself and his credentials are concerned, a video of an “Assembly of Experts” [Majlis Khobregan] meeting back in 1987 was released last week, in which it is clearly shown that:
    A) Khamenei himself insistently repeats that he is not eligible as the leader, and lack the required qualifications, stating that:
    ” خامنه‌ای: باید خون گریست بر جامعه‌ی اسلامی که احتمال رهبر شدن من در آن مطرح شود”
    “The Islamic society in which there is a possibility of me becoming a leader should tear blood.”
    And even after he is positioned in that leadership post, it is clearly affirmed that such a position is only temporarily and valid up to the election of that year 1987.
    This issue of historical legitimacy of the leader also brings us up to now, some 30 years later, when thousands of angry Iranians are chanting in the streets with slogans such as:
    -We don’t want Islamic Republic
    -Reformist, Conservative the game is over
    – Death to dictator
    and many other vociferous antagonistic slogan against the regime as a whole.
    History of dictatorships tends to show that any hint of Reform most often ends up in their demise, and Khamenei himself is very well aware of that, hence his attack on the protesters and calling them the agents of foreign powers.
    Rohany on the other hand still has illusions about reformability of this Totalitarian Theocracy aka Islamic Republic, but true to his mullah character he is still pushing the parliament to pass the increase of Gas price, and intends to balance his budget through people’s pockets, rather than cutting back on the enormous financial allocations for religious institutions and security forces, which essentially take 2/3 of his budget.
    To make a long story short, Islamic Republic has exhausted all its options and reached a dead end. Due to its violently ideological nature it can not reform itself, and it simply can’t continue to exist as it has done all along, since these nationwide protests are a blunt rejection of politics as usual.
    It can’t go forward or backward.
    Or as we say in Persian:
    “Nah rah pish, nah rah pas”
    And now the demand for freedom of political prisoners has become a mass demand of the people. In contrast to pre protest times when it was mainly a demand raised only by human rights and social activists.

    P.S. Various estimates put the number of people arrested around 3000, nationwide.

  3. The average donation as of this morning was over $77. That’s quite a high number.

    I think if you had a statement on your home page that small donations of $10 to $20 are greatly appreciated, you would soon reach your goal.

Comments are closed.