Informed Comment

Thoughts on the Middle East, History, and Religion

Juan Cole is President of the Global Americana Institute

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

"They even killed the cats!"

Some 50,000 Palestinians have been left homeless by the Israeli war on the people of Gaza, with 400,000 now lacking access to running water. Rebuilding what the Israeli military destroyed will cost billions of dollars.
Cont'd (click below or on "comments")

Ashraf Khalil of the LAT reports that the Israelis destroyed 21,000 buildings. Khalil writes from the scene:

' In the village of Fukhari, outside Khan Yunis, it seemed as if a powerful earthquake had struck, flattening a collection of 15 homes belonging to a single extended family, a swath of destruction the size of a city block. Israeli tanks and bulldozers rolled through this agricultural patch last week, destroying every building in sight. . . "They even killed the chickens and the turkeys!" shouted Faour Atteya, a 50-year-old high school teacher. "They killed the cats!"'


Aljazeera English reports on innocent civilian families buried in the rubble of farmhouses and other buildings demolished by Israeli air strikes.



Saudi Arabia pledged $1 bn. toward rebuilding Gaza at the Arab summit in Kuwait. This aid will likely be the main source of reconstruction, since Europe and the US refuse to deal with the Hamas government of Gaza, which the Israelis failed to dislodge. It should be pointed out that Saudi money will likely come with some strings attached, and may be disbursed in such a way as to try to spread the rigid Wahhabi branch of Islam. The Palestinians are the most secular people in the Arab world, but Israeli actions are pushing them into the arms of the conservative Gulf states. I don't think the Israelis will like the outcome down the road very much. But they seem to be unable to foresee the likely consequences of their actions. They invaded and occupied southern Lebanon in 1982, and seemed surprised when that occupation turned the Shiites against them and produced Hizbullah. They encouraged Hamas as an alternative to the secular Fatah in the late 1980s, and now seem surprised that Hamas overshadows Fatah.

The Israelis' brutal murder of hundreds of innocent Gazans, and wounding of thousands of women and children, in the war they just concluded will rebound on them in some horrible way. The campaign likely has already probably ensured the reelection in Iran of President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, who had faced a tough campaign this June. Likewise, the war much weakened the Palestinian Authority and the Fatah party of PA president Mahmoud Abbas, because the Palestinian public perceived it to be implicated in the attack on Gaza. The US and Israel won't talk to Hamas, and if Fatah has been discredited with the Palestinians, then the Iraelis really have no one to talk too. That may suit them now, but timeis not on Israel's side.

I recommend to both sides Leo Tolstoy's short story, "A Lost Opportunity."

Anyway, it seems obvious that Hamas's control of Gaza has not been destroyed, if that was the goal of the Israeli leadership, since Hamas's security men reemerged on Monday to combat looting and gouging among the survivors.

Stephen Walt points out at his new blog that the Israelis think they got deterrence with regard to Hamas because the operation restored their own confidence. But you only get deterrence if you break the will of the enemy, which manifestly did not happen.

If the point was to stop the rockets being fired by Hamas, the ceasefire of last June did that, despite Olmert's propaganda to the contrary, and a further ceasefire could have been arranged. If the point was to destroy Hamas, well, they didn't accomplish that.

Palestinian-Israelis, about 20% of the Israeli population, were deeply traumatized by the Gaza war and the government's repression of dissent. By 2030, a third of Israel will be Arab, and social peace inside the country is increasingly threatened by the Iron Wall tactics of the right-Zionist leadership. Some Israelis, such as Avigdor Lieberman, dream of making Israel Arabrein, but that might not be so easy to accomplish without significant negative consequences.

Israeli troops seemed to be withdrawing from Gaza with some speed on Monday.

Only 41 percent of Israelis thought that the war was a success, apparently convinced that the government of Ehud Olmert could have done more to completely wipe out Hamas.

Mark Levine asks, "Who will save the Palestinians?"

Tomdispatch.com has been doing good work intracing military influence on civilian society in the US.


du

11 Comments:

At 6:36 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

My husband is a Palestinians and I have traditionally been an advocate for non violent resistance. But, the West forgets that in order to work, it needs to confront not only the systems of the occupation, but needs wide spread coverage. Thus, the pressure on the suppressor is both internal and external. I look at the results of Bilin where there have been years of peaceful protest against the Israel "land seizure" wall. Sure, the Israeli Court ruled against the wall and said to change direction, but there was not changes to realities on the ground. The truth is, Israeli law and democracy does not extended through the institution of their executive to Palestinians.

Each generation has a reason to hate the Israelis more. I try to teach my children tolerance. To help them understand, no Israel had no right to be created, and to recognize this is to legitimize the system of colonization. (No wonder why Americans, most descending from European colonists, think this is so important.) But, there need was so desperate and their options so limited, that they should have welcomed their cousins, and need now to find a way to live peacefully. But, we have lost so many. The occupation has been a reality of the entirety of my husband and my 10 yo daughters life.

In the end of that ramble, my point is, I have one son who wants to go and fight as soon as he is old enough, because of this war. I have a daughter who thinks I have been to tolerant of Jewish history, and says "we will never forget." This does not get us anywhere, the endless destruction, the total callous view of each others lives....

 
At 7:46 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Withdrawing from Gaza with some speed on Monday

Golly, I wonder if there's anything significant about Tuesday?

 
At 11:47 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Well, those cats represented a potential threat by having claws. And the terrorist chickens and turkeys have been known to peck without cause!

 
At 12:52 PM, Anonymous Bruce Sims said...

"The Israelis' brutal murder of hundreds of innocent Gazans, and wounding of thousands of women and children, in the war they just concluded will rebound on them in some horrible way."
I, for one, simply do not understand why the Israeli government -and it's people given that Israel is supposedly a democracy but looking at their constitution will surprise you- do not 'get it'.
Unless -and until- the idea of a 'greater Israel' is put to bed(given up) there will be no peace.
And after Lebanon and Gaza, I will be boycotting any products or services that support Israel and urging others to do the same.
AND I will be hounding Obama and my supposed representative and Senators to change U.S. policy towards Israel.

 
At 12:57 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

You wrote "If the point was to stop the rockets being fired by Hamas, the ceasefire of last June did that, despite Olmert's propaganda to the contrary, and a further ceasefire could have been arranged." And undoubtly you are correct a ceasefire could have been arranged but could one have been arranged that met the needs of both Palestinians and Israelis? One of the Palestinians demands was a complete opening of the border crossings. Israel didn't want to open them for fear Hamas would just smuggle in more advanced weaponery. You can't really make your claim that it could have been renewed with the satisfaction of both parties. And I'm talking about legitamate fear not unfounded ones.

 
At 5:04 PM, Anonymous jungle said...

"One of the Palestinians demands was a complete opening of the border crossings. Israel didn't want to open them for fear Hamas would just smuggle in more advanced weaponery."

But this just illustrates the general problem: many conditions (of which this is but one) Israel insists must be imposed as part of any permanent peace settlement just cannot realistically allow the Palestinians to live a meaningful life or even provide for their minimum daily needs.

Gaza must import and export at some point, or they will always be 100% dependent on food handouts and mostly unemployed.

 
At 5:17 PM, Anonymous Wade "Griff" Griffin said...

The israelis destroyed it, they aren't going to spend ten cents or ten minutes of their own rebuilding it and now they want to dictate who does provide assistance:

Israel to keep tight grip on Gaza reconstruction

19 Jan 2009

Israel intends to exert control over the reconstruction of the Gaza Strip following its 22-day offensive, and is seeking guarantees that no U.N. projects will benefit Hamas, officials said on Monday.

Israel, which declared a unilateral cease-fire on Sunday, retains full control over Gaza's commercial crossings, through which goods and other materials for rebuilding must pass.

Smuggler tunnels under Gaza's border with Egypt, which were used by Hamas and many ordinary Palestinians to get around the Israeli-led blockade, were heavily bombed during the war and are, at least temporarily, out of commission.

That gives Israel enormous power to shape the recovery effort, which will be largely financed by the international community. Preliminary estimates put the damage at nearly $2 billion. Saudi Arabia said it would donate $1 billion.

Full piece Here

.

 
At 6:40 PM, Blogger Shirin said...

"looking at [Israel's] constitution will surprise you"

Just as it has conveniently never declared its borders, Israel has never adopted a constitution.

 
At 6:41 PM, Blogger Shirin said...

Israel never misses an opportunity to destroy an opportunity.

 
At 7:25 PM, Blogger Shirin said...

"Israel didn't want to open them for fear Hamas would just smuggle in more advanced weaponery."

The tunnels were being used to "smuggle in" things like food, medicine and other essentials of normal life blockaded by Israel.

 
At 12:10 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Israel is democratic for its own Jewish people. This democracy extends very little to the remaining Palestinians in the territories occupied in 1948 and none to the Palestinians in the territories occupied in 1967. During the apartheid regime, South Africa was also democratic, but for the whites only!!!

 

Post a Comment

<< Home