Informed Comment

Thoughts on the Middle East, History, and Religion

Juan Cole is President of the Global Americana Institute

Wednesday, July 01, 2009

Coda: Final Dispatch from Tehran

This message was received by email from Tehran three hours ago. I have anonymized it and made a couple of orthographical corrections and am passing it on for what it is worth. - JC

And on the thirteenth day Michael Jackson died. Voice of America and BBC Persian are back up, if intermittently, and we crowd around like the rest of the world for the latest news. It is almost a relief. Being a full-time revolutionary is hard work, difficult to sustain. Seeing the non-stop coverage, the obvious distraction of his passing, we grimly joke that Michael was a martyr for the cause. At least he had the decency to delay his death until the worst violence had already passed.

Things are going back to their regular marks. In the afternoons the parks fill up again with old ladies and young couples. There's badminton and soccer for kids to play at night. Well-dressed men in jackets and dress pants exercise on the cardio equipment provided by the city. The scenes around the squares, lately the places of so much celebration and trouble, are almost back to normal. Traffic is back. A car flies towards Ariashahr Square, a young man with slicked back hair and aviator glasses leans out of the passenger window chest first. He removes his shades and turns his palms upwards, beseeching the ladies in the car next to him to pull over. Unimpressed, or maybe they're being coy, the girls pull away and race ahead of their pursuers. The two boys give chase. Cops and basijis hang around the circle but do nothing, what do they care...?

Every young person I see I wonder, What were you doing three weeks ago? Who were you then? I look for signs of subversion. A girl wears a green headscarf. A kid shifts gears in his Kia Pride with an arm encased in a green cast. What does it mean? Together, in a crowd, the color green added up to something. Alone, spread apart and without context, they are just moments of coincidence.

Television has become almost unbearable. Stories alternate between the mundane and the absurd. The evening news shows us parents waiting outside of testing halls where their kids are taking the Konkur, the once-yearly high stakes university entrance exam. This year, more than ever, the Konkur is an act of faith. For the less than half who get accepted and manage to finish their studies, one wonders what kind of job market will await them. A friend remarks, We've got to be the most educated unemployed in the world. Sometimes it seems that all we do is attend class, schooling has become the ultimate distraction.

The report on the Konkur ends and the next item is the case of Neda Khanom. Like Jim Garrison in JFK, the reporter shows us step-by-step how her death could NOT have been the result of a single gunman. The caliber doesn't match, it occurred on side streets, why is there footage of her before the incident, etc.. The reporter hints ominously at darker forces active inside of the country, that her death was no doubt a setup by a foreign power. Even by IRI standards, the report is breathtaking. Rather than hide the incident or pretend like it never happened, they try to play it to their advantage. There seems to be nothing beyond the pale, no outrage too great...We reminisce about better days, when the lying had enough truth in it that you could at least fool yourself into believing.

Khoobe, khoobe, bezar begand. Harchi bishtar, baytar. Good, good, let them say it. The more the better. Hamintor khatra siatar mikonand. They'll only darken the line separating the people from the government. We sit and plot, kitchen revolutionaries at work. It is late and the drink is loosening our tongues. What we need is leadership. What about Mousavi? Poor Mousavi, all alone...If only Khomeini were still around, he would have put all of these guys in their places!, this last bit said by someone who has never accepted the Revolution. At 10 the neighbors start up, Allah Akbar! Allah Akbar! We keep drinking, pressing our hands flat against the table and wondering if maybe they're letting us thrash around for a few weeks even as the screws tighten...

Still...I've written elsewhere that none of this was supposed to happen. It remains true. It is the people, the mellat, that has taken on the most creative and unexpected role in this drama. Their scenario remains the least predictable, and therefore most hopeful, of all of the actors, foreign or Iranian. Iran's conspirators clearly did not expect the population to show up in such defiant numbers after June 12 and the truth be told, neither did many of us...

We are told, Mellat e Iran ra nashenakhtim. The state says that the turnout and election results shows that the world and by implication the opposition didn't understand the Iranian people. Mellat e Iran ra nashenakhtim. We didn't understand the Iranian people, say certain analysts in Europe and the U.S.. The vote proves that Ahmadinejad is loved and the West once again didn't get the "true Iran."

Still...as the unrest continues, daily taking new forms---Iran's innumerable revolutionary, religious, and national holidays promise to be new sites of protest--it would appear that it is the state and its band of fellow travelers in the West that has failed to understand what has happened...

Cats are on the prowl in the kuchehs and sidestreets of Tehran. They've never had it better. A two-year effort by the city to outfit the capital with trash bins has gone to waste. In a few nights of protest practically every bin in the city has been kicked over, stomped on, melted into its primal elements. Neighbors have gone back to placing trash-filled yellow and black grocery bags at the end of the alley (sar e kuche) at night. The cats wait until no one is around and then show up sniffing, padding about, looking for their night's food.

Throughout the capital there are deep marks etched onto the asphalt, mottled grooves in the shape of a blocky "u" from where the bin fires burned hot against the pavement. The scars run at regular intervals across Tehran's many neighborhoods, sometimes in overlapping pairs or threes. It will be some time before these blemishes are repaired. Entirely new roads will have to be built...

(Dedicated to the geniuses at Nokia/Siemens)

End/ (Not Continued)

11 Comments:

At 12:14 PM, Anonymous Dan said...

The green revolution is just starting...

 
At 12:39 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Beautiful and sad. Thank you for posting it.

 
At 1:05 PM, Blogger Naj said...

very nice.

 
At 2:32 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Very Iranian, very nostalgic, elegiac and resigned. Who knows? Everyone knows. The people at the top have forged a deal. The people on the bottom can stay there as far as the people on the top concerned. Forever. Sound familiar?

 
At 4:10 PM, Blogger karlof1 said...

Vijay Prashad has an excellent item published here constituting the best analysis of Iran's recent events I've read. It helps explain what is written in the email by providing it additional context.

It seems rather clear as Mark Weisbrot points out that little fraud occured in the Iranian election, which puts the actions by Mousavi in the same category as those by Sumate--the US-funded astroturf actor that cried foul in the same manner as Mousavi in order to delegitimize Chavez and the Venezuelan electoral process. Let me repeat that: The tactics of Sumate and Mousavi were identical. This implies influence exerted by the many governmental destabilization agencies within the US government. This made it very difficult to believe Mousavi was genuine--particularly when it was noted he favors a return to the "Khomieni's teachings."

My conclusion is we just witnessed another round in a longstanding struggle by sectors of Iranians for greater political freedoms to be made by the sectors of Iranians holding political and economic power and its failure due to its inability to unite disparate sectors of Iranins into a whole, with the election outcome providing a good barometer of just how much work needs to be done the next time. IMO, the quickest path to basic democratic freedoms and human rights for the Iranian people is for the USA and the EU to end their unfounded sanctions of the Iranian state and its institutions and ceasing the "Iran is THE Enemy" rhetoric, which will remove the very powerful "foreign intervention card" held by the ruling elite. The change wouldn't be instantaneous as trust needs to be earned by the USA and EU, which might take the generation of time already squandered by the West's idiotic Imperialist policy.

 
At 5:53 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

There is no "green" revolution, save for in the fantasies of Twitter "revolutionaries" and Western politicians and mainstream media.

 
At 9:04 PM, Anonymous Mari said...

Obama faces a Persian rebuff
By M K Bhadrakumar

http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Middle_East/KG01Ak03.html

 
At 9:40 PM, Anonymous Mari said...

Hezbollah keeps its eye on the ball
By Sami Moubayed

http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Middle_East/KF27Ak01.html

 
At 9:44 PM, Anonymous Mari said...

Maybe the U.S. should try and learn somethings from China...

COMMENT
China doesn't want Iran unstable
By Jian Junbo

http://www.atimes.com/atimes/China/KG01Ad01.html

 
At 10:00 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thank You Juan.....Again,My only

regret about leaving Detroit, is missing any talks, forums you may give, conduct..........

Sad commentary on the Iran election..

The green color attached to the protests...Is this empire rubbing it's [color coded] usurpations [shit] in the faces of the mulah's...

In the run up to the invasion of Iraq, a hundred thousand protesters marched in Washington against the gathering invasion and the government propaganda...It did no good.....

"They", the bush neocon cabal with it's mascot john bolton frothing at the mouth WAR...WAR...WAR marched on and we [the protesters] were left in the dust of history.

"They" , seized power in an rigged election had it ratified by the Mullah's [Supreme Court] and took the reigns to construct the false flag we call 911 to stampede the TV
nation into two wars at the cost of Trillions...

Their real goals were oil and the coronation of the king Middle East hegemon....Israel...

 
At 10:59 AM, Anonymous Dorothy said...

Beautifully sculpted writing. The author makes reference to previous writings. Do you have links to that? I'd love to see more. It reminds me a lot of writing that came out in the wake of the insurrection in Greece last December.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home