The Biggest threat to the Mideast isn’t ISIL, it’s bad, Corrupt Governance

By Marwan Muasher | (Project Syndicate) | – –

WASHINGTON, DC – A recent survey of 100 Arab thought leaders conducted by the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace revealed a sweeping consensus about what underlies many of the region’s problems: a lack of good governance. Indeed, those polled emphasized domestic problems resulting from that failure – authoritarianism, corruption, outdated education systems, and unemployment – over regional concerns, including the threat of the self-proclaimed Islamic State (ISIS) or interference by regional heavyweights or outside powers.

This is not new information. The Arab Spring uprisings brought to the fore the inadequacy of the region’s outdated social contracts in the face of current political and economic challenges. Yet Arab governments still seem not to have gotten the message.

Five years after the uprisings erupted, Arab citizens have little – in some cases, even less – voice in running their countries’ affairs. Moreover, they depend on rentier economies that are unable to create enough jobs for their young, educated populations. And they face an alarming absence of the rule of law, leaving them with no assurances that they will be treated equally, regardless of gender, ethnic origin, or religion.

But poor governance today does not mean the Arab world is doomed to failure. Tunisia serves as a beacon of hope. After the 2011 revolution, it pursued a consensual, inclusive process to develop a new social contract that upholds all of its people’s individual and collective rights.

While Tunisia still faces serious economic and security problems, the national dialogue that the country has undertaken is the crucial first step toward resolving them. Other Arab societies now must undertake similar dialogues, with the ultimate goal of creating economies and institutions that meet their people’s needs.

History has taught us that such transformational processes take time. The long-suppressed ideas and energies unleashed by events like the Arab Spring must mature before having their full effect on society.

Consider the uprisings in Europe in 1848, in which citizens protested against authoritarian, feudal systems and the lack of economic opportunity. By the end of that year, status quo forces managed to retake the reins of power, and the uprisings appeared to have been all but crushed.

But something had changed. Taboos had been broken, and during the subsequent decades, technological advances enabled the spread of new ideas. It was not long before feudalism began to dissolve; liberal and democratic values gained traction; women secured greater rights; and economic systems emerged that could boost productivity, achieve high growth rates, and improve living standards.

A similar process is unfolding gradually in the Arab world, with citizens (especially young people) who lack trust in their governments seeking alternative sources of information and new ways to survive economically. This shift has so far gone largely unnoticed by governments, a reflection of just how disconnected they are from their own people. But it will soon be impossible to ignore.

All of this comes at a time when another important development is underway: Oil-based rentier systems are rapidly diminishing, owing to the steep decline in energy prices over the last two years. In particular, Saudi Arabia has been forced to initiate a shift toward an economic model that emphasizes investment and productivity as the main drivers of economic growth. Other countries in the region will have to follow suit and reform their economic systems, or face the wrath of their increasingly disgruntled citizens.

One important element of economic-reform strategies will be technology. Already, 240 million Arabs – largely young people – have access to the Internet through mobile phones; by 2020, it is estimated that all Arab youth will be connected. Technology is facilitating the creation and sharing of knowledge, in a region that has historically lagged in this area, and technology start-ups are on the rise.

This is not to say that technology is a panacea for the region. After all, ISIS is also using technology, but in a sinister way: to spread gruesome propaganda and recruit new members. But technology can speed up the Arab world’s social and economic progress, even as countries build a modern institutional framework capable of supporting it.

Nowadays, no country can evolve without developing effective and credible institutions, establishing a meaningful system of political checks and balances, and diffusing control over decision-making. These elements are vital to enable countries to offer their citizens an adequate quality of life.

In time, the Arab world will have them. While the international community is focused on ISIS or Iran’s destructive role in the Middle East, most Arabs are focused on improving their lives. Their governments should encourage them.

Marwan Muasher, a former foreign minister and deputy prime minister of Jordan, is Vice President for Studies at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. His latest book is The Second Arab Awakening and the Battle for Pluralism.

Licensed from Project Syndicate

—-

Related video added by Juan Cole:

Carnegie Live: “Supporting Tunisia’s Imperiled Transition”

4 Responses

  1. Certainly bad government is a problem everywhere.

    But for governments to merely “offer their citizens an adequate quality of life” isn’t much of a goal. And how is that to be done without democracy and human rights, but only “effective and credible institutions” characterized only by “checks and balances, and diffusing control over decision-making”? Those goals were met by medieval monarchies as well as then possible, and they aren’t met well by the United States, except for its economic advantages, not much to be credited to its nondemocratic government.

    Try human rights, democracy, self-determination, economic opportunity, public education, and health.

  2. “In particular, Saudi Arabia has been forced to initiate a shift toward an economic model that emphasizes investment and productivity as the main drivers of economic growth. Other countries in the region will have to follow suit and reform their economic systems, or face the wrath of their increasingly disgruntled citizens.”

    The same could be said about countries in our region like the United States. Concentration of wealth in the hands of an ever shrinking percentage is increasing all over this country.

  3. As an Arab national I am impressed and appreciative to see a member of the “establishment” speaks what is on the people’s mind. In itself, a good sign of better days to come. Governance, however, is too big and abstract to make it actionable. As long as rulers have their own best interest as priority and their people are no more than subjects and a burden to govern and deal with, nothing will change. Tyranny is the source of all evil in the Arab world. It is the mother of corruption, despotism, and nepotism, that drains resources and drives out brain power away. The hope that divesting from oil to industry is a pipe dream that is likely to wipe out all funds in black holes of investment. Why? Because industrialization needs culture, work ethics, personal accountability, and transparency. These don’t just mushroom in the dark fed by manure, they take changes at the root cause of misery: Tyranny. No wonder, a man like Thomas Jefferson swore “upon the altar of God against every form of tyranny over the mind of man!”

  4. “While the international community is focused on ISIS or Iran’s destructive role in the Middle East ….”

    How do the ‘Arabs’ feel about Saudi Arabia’s carnage in Yemen?

Comments are closed.