DAPL: This Thanksgiving, Time to Listen to Native Americans again on Climate & Survival

Revised and updated.

By Juan Cole | —

The popular story about Thanksgiving is an environmental parable that we would do well to remember today. It was a harvest festival in 1621, participated in by the 50 (out of 100) survivors at Plymouth Plantation and 90 Native Americans. Some of these latter, such as Squanto, had shared with the white undocumented aliens arriving in Wampanoag territory their local techniques of fishing and corn farming. In some subsequent years there were droughts that threatened the colony.

If the Pilgrims faced Coldworld and its weather and agricultural challenges, today we face Hotworld. Just as they looked to the Native Americans for cues on how to survive in that cold environment, we should look at indigenous peoples’ current environmental initiatives to understand how to avoid heating the earth more than the further nearly 4 degrees F. that we already certainly will. (4 degrees F. is a global average, including the relatively cold oceans, and some places will experience a much greater increase in heat than that). It is obvious that the US Federal government will be useless or actually pernicious on this issue for some years to come, so we have to do this ourselves.

This is the donate button

Click graphic to donate via PayPal!

Today’s native Americans are fighting a wide range of human-caused climate crises or budding crises. There’s been relatively little coverage of it on corporate television news, but Native Americans of the Standing Rock Sioux tribe and their supporters in North Dakota have for months been protesting the Dakota Access Pipeline [DAPL] . They fear oil spills and pollution of their water supplies, a perfectly reasonable apprehension. What is worse, burning petroleum certainly causes climate change, and the more drilling and the more pipelines, the faster we cook everybody on earth. Despite the constitution’s guarantee of the right of assembly for peaceful protest, the local authorities and the corporations have conspired to criminalize these rallies. A few days ago, in the frigid weather, police unleashed water cannons and tear gas canisters on the protesters, leaving some hospitalized.

ABC News: “Police Use Water Cannon on Dakota Pipeline Protesters [Drone Footage]”

The DAPL struggle is not the only one being waged by indigenous communities.

Native Americans in Canada largely oppose tar sands oil extraction, which is highly polluting and ruinous of water supplies. T

The Sioux in South Dakota had announced that the Keystone XL pipeline for dirty tar sands oil must not run through their land, by treaty with the US. That pipeline project was denied by the Obama administration in 2015 after years of review.

The Moapa Paiutes are celebrating the advent of solar power and the beginning of the end of coal power in southern Nevada. The Department of Energy says, “Located 30 miles north of Las Vegas, the 250-megawatt solar photovoltaic project is being built by First Solar and is providing jobs and training for members of the Moapa Band of Paiute Indians (Moapa Paiutes).” Some 25% of the workforce building the plant are themselves Moapa Paiutes.

They are having a solar plant built on tribal lands, which will allow them meet their own needs and to sell electricity to Los Angeles. Best of all, they can envision the closing of the dirty coal plant that has given them respiratory diseases.

The Reid Gardner coal plant is indeed closing, in 2017, after the the tribe was paid $4.3 million because of its adverse health effects on them. The bulk of the money will be used for clean-up.

The Sioux and the Paiutes are our modern-day Squantos, teaching us how to live sustainably in a North America they have inhabited for thousands of years longer than have Euro-Americans. The Pilgrims, despite their conviction of European superiority, were humble enough to learn what they could from the natives, which was the only way they could survive. Can we be as humble, today?

The pilgrims in 1621 faced a harsher climate than had Leif Erikson when he came to North America around 980 during the European medieval warming period. From 1550 to 1850, temperatures in the Northern Hemisphere fell by an average of about 1.3 degrees F (1 degree C.), during what has been called “the Little Ice Age.” This fall in temperature was exacerbated in the 1500s and 1600s by a slight decrease in atmospheric carbon of 6 to 10 parts per million. Stanford University geochemist Richard Nevle has argued that the great die-off of Native Americans, who were exposed to European diseases for which they had no antibodies, contributed to this decrease of carbon dioxide and fall in temperature. They ceased burning trees for fuel, and the forests recovered, with millions of new trees absorbing CO2.

Science News explains:

“By the end of the 15th century, between 40 million and 100 million people are thought to have been living in the Americas. Many of them burned trees to make room for crops, leaving behind charcoal deposits that have been found in the soils of Mexico, Nicaragua and other countries.

About 500 years ago, this charcoal accumulation plummeted as the people themselves disappeared. Smallpox, diphtheria and other diseases from Europe ultimately wiped out as much as 90 percent of the indigenous population.

Trees returned, reforesting an area at least the size of California, Nevle estimated. This new growth could have soaked up between 2 billion and 17 billion metric tons of carbon dioxide from the air.”

That is, the cold winters that challenged the English immigrants (and which they played down in their letters back home) had in part been caused by the very European influx of which they were a part!

From about 1750, however, Europeans started substantially increasing their burning of wood and coal so as to drive steam engines and make the industrial revolution. In that year, there were roughly 278 parts per million of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere and it was relatively cold. Today there are over 400 ppm of CO2 in the atmosphere and it is on average over 2 degrees F. (1.5 degrees C.) warmer now than then.

We can make our Thanksgivings greener and greener in coming years.

We can make sure our homes are insulated, which will cut down on our fuel costs and carbon production, and will make them more cozy for guests.

We can put solar panels on our homes to generate electricity to run the television and other appliances for our family and guests.

Those who go to church, synagogue or mosque on Thanksgiving can make sure that their religious edifices are powered by solar panels. A temple that burns fossil fuels is paying dues to the devil, not glorifying the God of wisdom who commands good stewardship of earth.

We can drive to the homes of our family and friends for the dinner in electric cars or plug-in hybrids, fueled from the rooftop solar panels (which are falling steeply in price). If we fly, we can buy carbon offsets from the Nature Conservancy or eat vegetarian often enough to make up for it (solar-powered and biofuel-powered airplanes are around the corner).

We can lobby our electric utility to turn to wind turbines, as Iowa and Texas increasingly have, which supplements the solar generation. A third of Iowa’s electricity comes from wind. Not all states are equally blessed with its wind resources. But Michigan, e.g., does have promising wind generation areas in the Thumb and on the Lake Michigan shore, which it has quite shamefully done almost nothing with.


We can avoid beef, the most carbon-intensive protein (not so hard, since who eats beef on Thanksgiving?) and can try to buy local produce to prepare the meal.

Some will say these steps are not enough; but they are more than most Americans have undertaken and would be a good start.

Thanksgiving in the American popular tradition hasn’t only been about being thankful for food abundance. It has been gratitude for survival and adaptation in an alien clime. We are all now entering an alien clime, of a warming globe– a world hotter than it has been since the mid-Pliocene some 3 million years ago, when the seas were 25 yards/ meters higher and the northern hemisphere 10-20 degrees hotter than now (it had 400 ppm of carbon dioxide in its atmosphere too). Survival and adaptation require us now to change a lot of habits and become sustainable, and ASAP. Like the Pilgrims, half of whom died in their first year, we face an emergency.

4 Responses

  1. Juan….thanks for giving this: A temple that burns fossil fuels is paying dues to the devil, not glorifying the God of wisdom who commands good stewardship of earth.
    And a blessed Thanksgiving to you and your family!

  2. The brutality of the pipeline company against American and tribal citizens has been worthy of China. It is a disgrace and a failure of the system that police are backing up the aggressors rather than the citizens, who are clearly in the right on this issue. How do they look their families in the eyes at the end of the day?

  3. Thank you for all your academic work, I wish more people would pay attention to how distructive not paying attention is!

  4. I live in a NE Ohio “Rust Belt” city.
    There is a well-established “grow local” movement here, as well as larger numbers of folks who have their own gardens and we have built a number of neighborhood gardens as well. Solar is still too expensive for the people in my neighborhood, and I live in what was historically the “wealthier” (read: whiter) side of town. But some of us collect rain water, compost on a regular basis, and we have curbside recycling pickup. (I’ve even built a grey water recycling system which captures my laundry wash water for toilet flushing, and the cleaner rinse water for the next wash cycle.)

    So far, city government has allowed rainwater catchment, but I’ve heard of other municipalities inexplicably ban it. A growing issue for an already financially stressed citizenry like ours is the increasing water/wastewater bill. The USEPA has mandated sewer infrastructure improvements, but have allowed a 30yr time frame for completion. But the bulk of the cost is on everyday consumers here, and the city is trying to offset this. We only have to look at Flint to realize how important an environmentally safe water system is, and this is how a federally-funded public infrastructure project would help a city like ours. (Trump’s plan would be a privately run, “disaster crony- capitalism” project.)

    Also, our city provides tire and electronics recycling at least twice a year, but it’s always quite depressing to see the enormous piles of refuse that can appear on just about every street, especially as more homes are boarded up, and the contents removed. We have a tremendous number of homes slated for demolition, but there was no planning for the waste stream that’s been created.

    More local businesses – restaurants, hospital, etc – are buying more locally grown produce. But most of the city is a “food desert.” A large chain recently closed it’s stores, creating a problem for city residents who are now forced to travel to the suburbs for food. Those who can’t rely on the food bank, or resort to the unhealthy choices offered at small convenience stores.

    Sorry to digress, but my point is to show that even though most of us cannot afford higher tech options for going green, we’re still trying within our means to contribute. Native Americans have taught us the lesson of Seven Generations, and we’re trying to teach our younger generation here to think long term about the consequences of their actions.


Comments are closed.