Informed Comment

Thoughts on the Middle East, History, and Religion

Juan Cole is President of the Global Americana Institute

Thursday, December 20, 2007

Turkish Ambassador: US was Helpful;
600 attacks a week in Iraq;
Surge Exiled One Million Iraqis to Syria where they Face Starvation

The Turkish ambassador to the United States, Nabi Sensoy, said Wednesday that the US military provided real time intelligence to Turkey and was 'very helpful' in allowing Turkey to launch attacks on alleged Kurdish Workers Party (PKK) sites inside Iraq. He denied that the Turks had given the US military too little notice of its planned Sunday air raids, saying that the two militaries were in close contact. (Obviously, there is no point in the US providing 'real time' intelligence unless Turkey strikes immediately, so Sensoy's point seems well taken). The Nuri al-Maliki government in Baghdad condemned the Turkish military's incursion into northern Iraq on Tuesday, after the air strikes, as having "added insult to injury."

The Turkish actions deeply embarrassed US Secretary of State Condi Rice, who was on trip to Iraq to reinforce reconciliation among ethnic and religious groups when Turkey struck, twice. The leader of Iraq's Kurdistan Regional Authority, Massoud Barzani, cancelled his meeting with her and complained of the Turkish attacks as war crimes. The LA Times reports that Condi on Wednesday warned Turkey against actions that would have the effect of destabilizing northern Iraq. That is the only part of Iraq that is relatively calm (excepting Kirkuk Province).

Al-Hayat reports in Arabic that according to the lunar, Muslim calendar, the Eid al-Adha or Feast of Sacrifice in memory of God's sparing of Abraham's son, which Muslims are now commemorating, also marks the anniversary of the execution of Saddam Hussein. In Tikrit, dozens of Iraqis, including local tribal chiefs (presumably of the Al-Bu-Nasr), visited the tomb of Saddam at al-Awjah. The Iraqi Baath Party called for international commemorations of Saddam Hussein's 'martyrdom.'

Al-Hayat also says that the so-called "Army of Islam" guerrilla group in Iraq released a video showing how one of its leading snipers shoots down US troops.

The United States military in Iraq has arrested and imprisoned 30,000 or so Iraqis, the majority of them Sunni Arabs. That is 0.1% of the entire Iraqi population! Marine Maj. Gen. Doug Stone says he fears that many of those detained are moderates or simply fought because they were paid to, and that holding so many of them together for very long may actually create more hardened terrorists.

Some 23 Iraqis were killed by bombings and sniping on Tuesday, including more than one attack in Diyala province and four killed and wounded 7 in a bombing in Baghdad itself. Reuters has more on recent violence in Iraq.

The guerrilla movement in Iraq is generating a steady 600 attacks a week using bombs, small-arms, mortars and sniping. This number has not changed during the past six weeks, and although it is lower than the rate in September, it is a very significant number of attacks. Roadside bomb attacks in specific are down, but there is no change in the number of over-all attacks. The Iraqi government statistics show 600 civilian deaths a month (the US military's statistics are lower).

The US troop escalation that began last February seems to be implicated in the displacement of nearly one million Iraqis to Syria between January and October of this year, adding to the nearly 450,000 that fled there in 2006. This is according to projections from a United Nations weighted survey of nearly 800 refugees. Some 78% of those interviewed in Syria said that they came from Baghdad.

Many of the refugees are from the white collar middle class, and are the people Iraq can least afford to lose. Most of them are only 3 months or less from exhausting all their saving and being thrown into complete destitution. Children are not being educated, and literacy is falling dramatically in the next generation. Many girls are forced into 'survival sex,' i.e. prostitution.

How the US 'surge' drove almost one million Iraqis to Syria last spring and summer is a great mystery, and casts severe doubt on its political success. A significant proportion of these one million Surge Victims appear to have been Baghdad Sunnis, since from January of 2007 through July 2007 the US military admits that Baghdad went from being 65% Shiite to being 75% Shiite. Since another 500,000 left between July and October, depending on what proportion of those were Sunnis, Baghdad could now be even more than 3/4s Shiite. The Sunnis are not going to take this lying down, and the 'surge' seems to me to have set the stage for 1) a violent return of hundreds of thousands of Sunni Arabs to their usurped homes in Baghdad and 2) therefore a second Battle for Baghdad as soon as the US forces in Iraq are too weak to prevent it.

The UN report preliminary data are here (.pdf).

Finally, McClatchy pointed out this week that the relative reduction of violence, especially in some districts of the capital of Baghdad, has brought no tangible political and ethnic reconciliation.

Labels:

14 Comments:

At 7:49 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

How can a limited 24-hour operation in remote mountains destabilize the north of Iraq?

 
At 11:42 AM, Anonymous Andy Scheidl said...

C'mon Juan,

We depend on you for independent, insightful commentary. Portraying the refugees from Iraq as 'Surge Victims' is just over the top. Rewind to summer and fall of 2006, or even the battle of Baghdad through this year. These folks were not fleeing US troops. They were fleeing chronic sectarian violence. You can lay that sectarian violence at the feet of the whole Iraq endeavour, but an indictment against the Surge just doesn't stick. You need to give credit and blame where they're due.

Apart from that, please keep up your valuable work.

Andy Scheidl

 
At 12:30 PM, Blogger Brian said...

It is not surprising that 78% of Iraqis in Syria reported that they were from "Baghdad", as Baghdad is one of the few cities that would not reveal sectarian/ethnic affiliations. This appeared to be a survival strategy amongst many of the refugees in Damascus, although upon deeper scrutiny you would find they actually came from Ramadi, Fallujah, Najaf, etc.

 
At 2:31 PM, Blogger jsb said...

So how many of the exiles in Syria are murderous Baathist bastards who should never return to Iraq anyway? These people have been running a shiite killing machine for decades. I'm not shedding any tears.

 
At 2:52 PM, Anonymous John Francis Lee said...

' The United States military in Iraq has arrested and imprisoned 30,000 or so Iraqis, the majority of them Sunni Arabs. That is 0.1% of the entire Iraqi population! '

Take a deep breath, Juan Cole.

' In 2005, about 1 out of every 136 U.S. residents was incarcerated either in prison or jail. The total amount being 2,320,359, with 1,446,269 in state and federal prisons and 747,529 in local jails. '

That's 0.7% of the entire American population, Juan!

It would be fantastic if we had a mere 0.1% of the entire population behind bars in America!

The United States has 5% of the world's population and 25% of the world's incarcerated population.

"Land of the free." Right. The "they" in the "They hate our freedom" is the Republicrat/Demoblican Party.

"They" is the Neocon putsch that took invaded with Ronald Raygun, occupied America under Bill and Hillary Clinton, and "surged" over the abyss with George XLIII. The American prison population has qudrupled since 1980.

"War on drugs" or "war on terror" makes no difference : It's the American people in the crosshairs either way.

 
At 3:26 PM, Blogger The Buffalo In The Midst said...

"...and that holding so many of them together for very long may actually create more hardened terrorists."

You could extend that example to American society where 40% or so of all black males have been imprisoned at some point in their life.

Remember we are exporting 'American Democracy' and the prison-industrial complex is a major part of it.

It is said that California cannot elect a governor who doesn't have the support of the prison guards 'union' (quotes intentional).

Guess what THEY want more than anything else?

Job security. Revolving door prisons to warehouse the people "tracked" into endless criminal recidivism due to social factors created by a society where 1% of the people have ...99% (+-?) of the 'stuff'.

Guess what the Pentagon wants more than anything else?

Job security. (Endless war... and rumors of war, and preparations for war).

The finest democracy money can buy is being forced right now on the people of Iraq.

Leigh

 
At 3:56 PM, Anonymous laughingriver said...

How the US 'surge' drove one million Iraqis to Syria last spring and summer is a great mystery, and casts severe doubt on its political success.

That's easy, if your a Sunni, you by definition are identified with the insurgency. When the "Surge" was announced, as primarily an operation against the Sunni insurgency, well, then you best pack your bags and exit before you are added to the statistics of those 30,000 Sunnis that are already being held by the American forces who likely had nothing to do with the insurgency either.

Not to mention that the Shia knew this was the perfect opprotunity to use the US military to assist them in ethnically cleansing the city of Baghdad.

So all in all it makes perfect sense and gives cause to the real reason violence is down so much in Baghdad. I bet the Saudis and the other Sunni countries are just pleased as punch by how all this turned out.

 
At 4:02 PM, Blogger workshop said...

As far as I can tell, the Surge was a boon to Shiite ethnic cleansing. And now it's a boon to Sunni warlords who are being paid and armed. Gee, what could be next? Peace? Well, I HOPE so...

 
At 5:04 PM, Blogger Peter Attwood said...

What you might have mentioned before now concerning those driven into Syria is that all this misery is clearly intentional US policy. It's intended to over-burden and destabilize Syria.

Why should you expect the US Congress to take responsibility for the mess and give them relief, when they would be relieving the condition they hope to gain advantage from?

Genocide in Iraq has been "worth it," as Madeleine Albright explained over 10 years ago, since 1991, when they decided to destroy all the water treatment plants in order to cause disease and death so as to put "pressure" on Saddam Hussein's regime.

The world failed to understand the kind of ideology underlying such a genocidal mindset 70 years ago. Many of us are making the same mistake today.

I don't know exactly what to do about it - maybe nothing is possible today, either, given the denial that blinds us when we most need to be see. But getting a clear understanding of how it really is must be the place to start.

 
At 6:29 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dr. Cole,

Mr. Bush this morning was applauding Iraqis for achieving some reconciliation at the local level,
even though there was not so much progress on reconciliation at the national level.

This is news to me.
Do you know what local reconciliation he refers to ?

Is he talking about reconciliation between tribal groups of the same sect ?
While that would be good,
it is well short of what I reasonably inferred.

your Avid Student

 
At 9:16 PM, Blogger nadia n said...

Everyone knows that the mass refugee migration started well before the surge, I don't get why you're implying that correlation=causation.

 
At 11:16 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

This is worth reading - Barry McCaffrey's latest trip report after visiting Iraq 5-11 December:

http://www.smallwarsjournal.com/documents/iraqaardec2007.pdf

 
At 12:37 AM, Blogger gandhi said...

I am looking forward to another blog post soon from Riverbend, whose family went into exile about this time and seem to fit Juan's demographic quite closely.

 
At 4:41 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

'So how many of the exiles in Syria are murderous Baathist bastards who should never return to Iraq anyway? These people have been running a shiite killing machine for decades. I'm not shedding any tears.'

Hear hear. Although the worst of them are being feted in Jordan, including Raghad his daughter.

Juan what chance do you think the sunnis have of winning the war they started in 2004/2005 for baghdad? The shia who left then are back in their old homes or those of sunnis and the militias are roaming the streets.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home