Informed Comment Homepage

Thoughts on the Middle East, History and Religion

Header Right

  • Featured
  • US politics
  • Middle East
  • Environment
  • US Foreign Policy
  • Energy
  • Economy
  • Politics
  • About
  • Archives
  • Submissions

© 2025 Informed Comment

  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Israel/ Palestine

“No other Land”: When Ordered to Destroy, we Sometimes have a Moral Obligation to Lie

Shamai Leibowitz 03/04/2025

Tweet
Share
Reddit
Email

( The Times of Israel ) – You are ordered—like in the Oscar-nominated documentary No Other Land—to demolish the homes, schools, and wells of Palestinian families in Masafer Yatta, a community in the West Bank that has existed since the early 1900s. The official reason: to clear the land for a live-fire military training zone.

But when you arrive, something shifts. You see the faces of children whose classrooms are about to be erased, parents clinging to the walls of homes passed down through generations, elders who have known no other land. You feel the weight of the injustice, the unbearable cruelty of the state-sponsored mission.

So you refuse. You turn back.

Later, the Israeli government official overseeing the operation asks you to describe what happened.

If you lie—and say you carried out the orders—you will have saved these people’s homes, their schools, their community.

If you tell the truth, the bulldozers will return, and the destruction will be inevitable.

According to Jewish law, what should you do?


” Woman sitting on the ruins of her house’ destroyed by Israel in Masafer Yatta, January 2023. Author שי קנדלר . Licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license. Via Wikimedia Commons.

You are definitely allowed to lie to save the homes and classrooms from destruction, since it is permitted to lie to save yourself or others from serious harm. The only dilemma the Talmud discusses (Yevamot 65b) is whether you are required to lie in this type of situation. As usual, we find two opinions:

1.It’s permitted to say a falsehood to prevent harm to others.
(מותר לשנות מפני השלום)

2.It’s a mitzvah to say a falsehood to prevent harm to others.
(מצווה לשנות מפני השלום)

When the Rambam codified this principle, he used language that permits lying, specifically in situations where it helps avoid embarrassment for oneself or others (Hilchot Gezeilah Va’aveidah 14:13).

However, in this case, the issue at hand is not merely about embarrassment. An entire community, along with its institutions and means of livelihood, is at risk. The Rambam’s broader rulings on saving lives and treating strangers with fairness lead to the conclusion that lying is not just permissible, but an obligation—a mitzvah!

Reprinted with the author’s permission from The Times of Israel

Filed Under: Israel/ Palestine

About the Author

Shamai Leibowitz is an adjunct professor of Hebrew and a Torah reader in his synagogue in Silver Spring, MD. He blogs at https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/author/shamai-leibowitz/

Primary Sidebar

Support Independent Journalism

Click here to donate via PayPal.

Personal checks should be made out to Juan Cole and sent to me at:

Juan Cole
P. O. Box 4218,
Ann Arbor, MI 48104-2548
USA
(Remember, make the checks out to “Juan Cole” or they can’t be cashed)

STAY INFORMED

Join our newsletter to have sharp analysis delivered to your inbox every day.
Warning! Social media will not reliably deliver Informed Comment to you. They are shadowbanning news sites, especially if "controversial."
To see new IC posts, please sign up for our email Newsletter.

Social Media

Bluesky | Instagram

Popular

  • Israel's Netanyahu banks on TACO Trump as he Launches War on Iran to disrupt Negotiations
  • Iran's Hypersonic Missiles Hit Israeli Refinery, Military Sites, as Israel does the same to Tehran
  • A Pariah State? Western Nations Sanction Israeli Cabinet Members
  • Israel: Will Ultra-Orthodox Jews' Opposition to Conscription Bring down Netanyahu's Gov't
  • Women's Cancer Rates are Rising in the Oil Gulf: is Global Heating causing it?

Gaza Yet Stands


Juan Cole's New Ebook at Amazon. Click Here to Buy
__________________________

Muhammad: Prophet of Peace amid the Clash of Empires



Click here to Buy Muhammad: Prophet of Peace amid the Clash of Empires.

The Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam


Click here to Buy The Rubaiyat.
Sign up for our newsletter

Informed Comment © 2025 All Rights Reserved