Iraq’s Christians Urged to Flee, al-Maliki Says they Should Stay, and Everyone Wonders where the Government Is

Update:: The NYT is reporting that on Wednesday morning, more bombings targeted Christians in Baghdad, leaving 3 dead and 28 wounded. Some of those hit were Muslims racing to help Christian neighbors. The bombers are radical Sunni Muslim extremists, “al-Qaeda” in the current parlance though they probably have nothing to do with Usama Bin Laden, who are bombing Shiites and Christians in the Iraqi capital to punish what they see as collaboration with the American invaders. The allegation of collaboration is incorrect– Iraqi Christians are nationalists and many were in the Baath Party or at least preferred it to more sectarian parties. And many Shiites in Baghdad are anti-American. But in extremist-world, symbols trump reality, and that the Americans are largely Christian and that they installed a Shiite government is all that counts.

In the wake of last week’s horrific bombing of Our Lady of Salvation church in Baghdad by Sunni Muslim extremists, , a Syriac Orthodox bishop residing in Britain, Archbishop Athanasios Dawood, called upon Iraq’s Christians to emigrate en masse. He says that the US and European countries, as well as neighbors such as Syria and Lebanon, should offer them asylum. There are said to be about 400,000 Christians left in Iraq, down from 800,000 before Bush’s invasion.

Caretaker prime minister Nuri al-Maliki, who visited Our Lady of Salvation church in Baghdad, however, warned against Western states encouraging Iraq’s Christians to leave.

Dawood told CNN, “I say clearly and now — the Christian people should leave their beloved land of our ancestors and escape the premeditated ethnic cleansing. This is better than having them killed one by one…”

Dawood says that the Iraqi government is at best incapable of protecting the country’s Christians, and at worst itself riddled with extremists. He told Aljazeera that in this regard, the Baath government of Saddam Hussein had been better. Christians could live and worship in pre-American Iraq. Now, he says, living in Iraq is like living in the jungle.

Al-Maliki praised France for giving asylum to Iraqi Christians harmed by the church bombing in Baghdad last week, but he cautioned against emptying Iraq out of its Christian citizens through changes in Western immigration rules. Dawood’s position runs up against a tradition of Iraqi nationalism that takes pride in the country’s diversity and its minorities, which al-Maliki is invoking. Dawood is of course implicitly blaming al-Maliki for not providing security to Iraq’s Christians.

Aljazeera English has video:

Christians predominated in Iraq before the Muslim conquests of the seventh century and only gradually for the most part converted to Islam. The 400,000 remaining Iraqi Christians thus uphold a tradition that goes back before the advent of Islam. But extremists often configure them as collaborators with the Americans, who are seen as Christians and Jews.

The US invasion of Iraq and the sectarian struggles it kicked off have left nearly 4 million Iraqis displaced, about 1 million of those abroad and 2.7 million inside the country. There is no sign of them returning to their homes, since their neighborhoods have been ethnically cleansed and their property mostly confiscated.

Many Iraqis feel that the deterioration of security is linked to the failure of Iraqi politicians to form a new government, 8 months after the March 7 elections. Not only is the executive a caretaker one, but Parliament has only met once. Members are accused of taking monstrous salaries and a fourth of them of living opulently abroad. Meanwhile bombings are taking a toll.

Aljazeera English has video:

3 Responses

  1. al-qaeda is not Sunni, but of the Salafi sect, which rejects what makes one a Sunni [Ash’ari and Maturidi Belief System]

    al-qaeda threatens hanafi Sunni scholars in Iraq all the time, assassinating them, blowing up their mosques, killing Sufis, blowing up sufi khanqas and tekkes.

    al-qaeda attacks Shafii Sunni scholars among the kurds in the north, blowing up naqshbandi and qadiri khanqas, mosques

    in Baghdad, Sunnis have a religious organization to fight these radical Salafi extremists

    these salafi [not sunni] radicals are at odds with other salafis who are not radicals, and call those sover Salafis as Madkhalis, a common word in saudi these days

    Non-radical Salafi = Madkhali
    radical Salafi extremist = al-qaeda

    al-qaeda are radical Salafi extremists, not radical Sunni extremists

    just because al-qaeda uses the umbrella phrase “ahl al sunnah”, does not mean it is Sunni

    The point of this post is to do justice to the vast majority of the Sunni Muslims in Iraq, particularly the Kurds, who have nothing to do with radical salafi extremists called al-qaeda, a concept alien to iraq until recently.

    Its kind of disheartening to see Sunni Muslims, who make up the vast majority of the Muslim populace being pushed in with a tiny radical sect as one whole group.

    Iraqi Sunnis have been admirers of Abdul Qadir Jilani in Baghdad.

    radical salafi extremists = al-qaeda, and their arch enemy the shiites, both tried to blow up his shrine

    radical salafi extremists even wanted to remove the grave of Imam Abu Hanifa, but were resisted by the Sunnis in Adhamiyya

  2. Question Professor:
    So G. Bush created the situation for the ethnic cleansing of Christians from Iraq? Is that what “Iraqi Freedom” was all about? Dang, seems some really bad juju to me.

  3. Are you surprised there is a feeling among Muslims that Iraqi Christians have a special relationship with the West, when all the injured from the church attack are invited to Paris for medical treatment? Muslim Iraqis don’t get that.

    Even for Archbishop Dawood to call for Christians to flee, implies that there is somewhere for them to go. Like a visa for the west. All Muslims can do is go to Damascus, and even that is difficult these days, I imagine.

Comments are closed.