Informed Comment Homepage

Thoughts on the Middle East, History and Religion

Header Right

  • Featured
  • US politics
  • Middle East
  • Environment
  • US Foreign Policy
  • Energy
  • Economy
  • Politics
  • About
  • Archives
  • Submissions

© 2025 Informed Comment

  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Member Profile

Total number of comments: 39 (since 2013-11-28 15:55:17)

Marshalldoc

Showing comments 39 - 1
Page: 1

  • Donald Trump claims torture 'works' – but what does the science say?
    • Marshalldoc 12/15/2016 at 3:24 pm with 1 replies

      I'm sorry but what's the point of this article and why is it legitimizing the 'does torture work?' debate as though the question has not already been definitively answered in infinite iterations since the issue first came to light and as though the Senate Torture Report did not answer the question with a definitive "NO!"? The question is not whether or not torture works, but why is anyone still advocating it as a useful means of interrogation, what is their ulterior agenda, and what is the 'damage' they're exhibiting [as in; 'What is your damage??]? Has the author slept through the last decade?

  • Will Turkey leave NATO for Sino-Russian Shanghai Cooperation Council?
    • Marshalldoc 11/25/2016 at 11:03 am

      Excellent discussion of this topic here: link to youtube.com

  • Is Lt.-Gen. Flynn Right that Islam is not a Religion?
    • Marshalldoc 11/20/2016 at 11:50 am

      Islam is not a religion when your definition of 'religion' is Christian; just as with the Christian extremists' flip-side, Wahhabism in which 'religion' is Islam. In the era of post-truth words mean what you want them to mean... don't bother with archaic concepts like 'definitions' & 'dictionaries'.

  • Putin targets East Aleppo rebels; Did Trump's Election doom them?
    • Marshalldoc 11/10/2016 at 12:21 pm with 1 replies

      Shouldn't the title read: "Assad & Putin target al Qaeda In East Aleppo. Did Trump’s Election doom them?" One can only hope....

  • Civilians in both Aleppos are Hurting
    • Marshalldoc 11/03/2016 at 3:46 pm

      "...abuses by rebels against civilians in western Aleppo have largely gone unreported. This is partly due to the challenges that independent observers like Human Rights Watch face in getting visas to the west of the city and other government-held areas, but also because many people in western Aleppo are afraid to talk to human rights groups because they fear government repercussions."

      What a load of NGOIC crapola!! How come journalists like Eva Bartlett (currently in Syria) & Vanessa Beeley (recently returned) have no difficulty whatever in accessing West Aleppo and reporting on the continuous barrage of gas canisters packed with explosives, shrapnel, and chlorine gas launched by U.S.-NATO-GCC-supported jihadi (Oh! Excuse me... 'moderate pro-democracy rebels') 'hellcannons' on the 1.5 million residents & refugees under Syrian government protection in West Aleppo? Well, the answer is simple... they don't want to go there because, heretofore, the reality-baed narrative would detract from the western agitprop agenda of 'evil dictator & evil Russians murder innocent freedom-loving Syrian men, women, & children because they love murdering innocent men, women, and children so the democracy-loving democracies of the WEST must ACT in order to save them from the government they elected by a landslide by creating a situation leading to potential confrontation between the world's largest nuclear-armed powers". This weeping 'we try so hard to tell all sides if only they'd let us' histrionics just don't cut it.

  • N. Dakota Judge Laughs Riot Charges against Amy Goodman out of Court
    • Marshalldoc 10/18/2016 at 1:13 pm

      Sadly though, there's no penalty for those committing 'persecution under color of law' such as happened to Amy Goodman & Deia Schlosberg. Yet, the prime objective - the interference with unrestricted open journalism - was nevertheless accomplished. The only means of stopping this 'official interference' is for there to be stringent legal penalties, applied immediately, for such 'legal' transgressions... not holding my breath.

  • Stopping the War on Children
    • Marshalldoc 09/22/2016 at 3:54 pm

      Let's stop using 3rd world children as media props for regime change!! link to youtu.be

  • No, Obama did not found ISIL, Mr. Trump: That was the GOP
    • Marshalldoc 08/11/2016 at 12:43 pm

      Difficult to separate the rise of Daesh, an offshoot of the ISI (organized during the Bush administration's invasion of Iraq) from the rise of al-Qaeda (ISI's 'parent') organized by Democrat Jimmy Carter & Saudi Arabia during the Afghan mujahedin's war on the Soviet presence in Afghanistan - perhaps a product of U.S. geopolitical machinations in southern Europe & central Asia after the demise of Operation Gladio... so-called 'Galdio B'. So, it's futile to make an argument that condemns either U.S. political party; the culprit is U.S. exceptionalism, imperialism, hubris, and neoliberal Capitalism augmented by both the "Carter Doctrine" & the "Wolfowitz Doctrine".

  • Donald Trump Knows Nothing About Muslims
    • Marshalldoc 08/01/2016 at 6:26 pm with 1 replies

      Hard to imagine why Muslims rate higher than the plethora of other things Trump knows nothing about - other than that his ignorance on this particular issue has the potential to cause one specific identity group serious harm while his comprehensive ignorance of all things relevant to the office he seeks has to potential to do remediable harm to all humanity. That is not to say, however, that he is a greater evil than Clinton; a proven warmonger and tool of the MIC & Wall Street and who harbors psychopathy of a magnitude similar to Trump's. There's only one sane candidate in this election: Jill Stein.

  • Is the French Press Right to stop Printing Pictures, Names of Terrorists?
    • Marshalldoc 07/28/2016 at 4:03 pm

      Does that mean they're not going to print "George W. Bush", "Richard Cheney", "Condoleezza Rice", "Tony Blair", "Barak Obama", "Susan Rice", "Samantha Power", and a whole host of other names that go along with these or is it only aimed at non-western 'terrorists"?

  • How can Americans prevent an Israeli-Iranian War? Dump the Squatter Settlers
    • Marshalldoc 06/27/2016 at 5:25 pm

      Mr. Buonomo's framing of this issue is odd. On the one hand he makes valid and useful commentary on the self-destructive nature of the Zionist settler-colonial project (understanding that the entire project would never be accepted under 'modern' view of human rights) but at the same time regurgitates tired NeoCon talking points: As if Assad should 'step down'... by whose authority? The divine provenience of American omniscience? Understanding that the legitimacy of elected governments has no bearing on their vulnerability to overthrow (aka: 'regime change') by the the U.S. & its proxies in the NeoCon's worldview tends to give insight into the writer's own worldview. And, 'Iran continues to expand its presence in Syria..." uh... excuse me, but Iran's there at Syria's request; unlike the U.S. & its regime change proxies. Lastly, the 'holocaust card'... really! Hasn't there been sufficient discussion over the intentional mistranslation of Iranian comments regarding the disappearance of Israel? Again, to be clear, the end of the Zionist state will no more require a genocide of Jews than the end of the USSR required a genocide of either Russians or even Communist Party officials. These memes continue to be tirelessly blathered about in ostensibly 'intellectual' essays. It gets so tiresome...

  • Are Israelis and Zionists really talking about a Final Solution of the Palestinian Problem?
    • Marshalldoc 08/02/2014 at 6:20 pm

      As one of European extraction (meaning I carry the genes of Neandethals in my cells), I resent the implied slur against my distant ancestors who, as far as we know, never advocated for genocide.

  • Gaza: Analysis shows Israel Keeps Changing Justification
    • Marshalldoc 08/02/2014 at 5:58 pm

      Regarding the question of 'Israel's end-game' the answer's been clear since Theodore Hertzl first created the Zionist project: A 'Greater Israel' encompassing (at least) all of 'Palestine' with a purely Jewish population (the fate & disposition of the 'current occupants' was, to quote neoliberal economist Alan Greenspan an "externality". I.e.: irrelevant). This disregard for the Palestinians became clear in '48 with the terrorism & ethnic cleansing of the Palestinians which has continued unabated. Most members of the Israeli Knesset have been openly verbal in their commitment to a Jewish ethnocracy in Israel and, thus, have absolutely no moral qualms to the current round of genocide. Whether or not the they'd behave differently in the exceedingly unlikely case of a complete U.S. embargo on military goods & other supplies will likely never be tested.

  • Gaza: Why a 'Cease-Fire' is Not enough
    • Marshalldoc 07/29/2014 at 6:32 pm

      Alon, I don't know when you were in school in Israel or what you were taught, but here's a selection of recent articles speaking to the issue... read 'em & weep:

      Biased new study skirts around racism in Israeli school books
      link to electronicintifada.net

      Jewish girls, beware of the 'evil' Arab doctor
      link to haaretz.com

      ‘San Jose Mercury News’ runs many pictures of Israeli children caressing guns
      link to mondoweiss.net

      When Israelis Teach Their Kids To Hate
      link to m.forward.com

      Parental love, Israeli-style
      link to haaretz.com

      Tel Aviv high school principal facing dismissal for writing leftist op-ed in Haaretz
      link to haaretz.com

      Knesset rejects bill promoting education against racism in Israeli schools
      link to haaretz.com

    • Marshalldoc 07/29/2014 at 6:27 pm

      Alon, I've no idea when you were in school, but here's a selection of articles about current issues relating to racism & Israel's approach to educating children... read 'em & weep:

      Biased new study skirts around racism in Israeli school books
      link to electronicintifada.net

      Israeli-Palestinian Textbook Study Overlooks Core Issue
      link to adl.org

      Jewish girls, beware of the 'evil' Arab doctor
      link to haaretz.com

      ‘San Jose Mercury News’ runs many pictures of Israeli children caressing guns
      link to mondoweiss.net
      When Israelis Teach Their Kids To Hate
      link to m.forward.com

      Parental love, Israeli-style
      link to haaretz.com

      Tel Aviv high school principal facing dismissal for writing leftist op-ed in Haaretz
      link to haaretz.com

      Knesset rejects bill promoting education against racism in Israeli schools
      link to haaretz.com

    • Marshalldoc 07/29/2014 at 6:16 pm

      That pretty much sums it up, Simon.

    • Marshalldoc 07/27/2014 at 5:00 pm

      Juan, I think the discussion is predicated on an erroneous supposition; i.e.; "the Israelis really want peace with their Palestinian neighbors". Wrong!! The Zionist project is, and always has been 'Greater Israel' and to hell with the Palestinians (including Christian Palestinians). Where they go, and under what circumstances are as Alan Greenspan would say 'externalities' as regards the goal and one knows about means & ends. So, don't expect any 'rational' (by our standards) behavior from Israel until you begin dealing with what their expectations are in reality. Once understood, then one can begin to 'negotiate' from knowledge. Until then, it'll be MOS with the same outcome (and one knows how to define an action repeated in the expectation of a different outcome).

  • Rep. Peter King sees Red over Pulitzers Honoring Snowden, Journalists covering NSA
    • Marshalldoc 04/16/2014 at 7:00 pm

      I think it's important to understand that the right-wing (by which I mean anyone to the right of Dennis Kucinich or Al Grayson; including the GOP & the 'Blue-dog' Dims) pay only lip-service to their oaths. What they actually support is Mussolini-style fascism in which they & their corporate fellow-travelers govern to suit their own best interests & reap benefits they deny to the hoi-poloi, while permitting sufficient benefits, to sufficient numbers of the 'hoi' as to stave off open rebellion while keeping the numbers of those sufficiently disenfranchised as to contemplate rebellion too low to accomplish it. Keep in mind 'democracy' is "government by 'the people". The term does not specify 'ALL the people'. People like Peter King draw a distinction between those entitled to govern and those to be governed.

  • US: Stop Blocking Palestinian Rights! (HRW)
    • Marshalldoc 04/08/2014 at 2:50 pm

      Fellow at 'Barracuda VPN' says 'won't work'...

    • Marshalldoc 04/08/2014 at 2:40 pm

      Tks... have neither. Am PC only.

    • Marshalldoc 04/07/2014 at 9:35 pm with 1 replies

      Okay... looked up 'VPN' on Wikipedia. See vendors listed in Google Search. Will investigate.

    • Marshalldoc 04/07/2014 at 1:36 pm with 1 replies

      Any suggestions on how to watch AJ/E videos now that they've blocked 'em in the U.S. in deference (I suppose) to AJ/AM? I had a major collection of AJ/E videos (esp. from 'Inside Story' with Shihab Ratansi) that became useless after AJ/E determined to censor its U.S. content. I now get AJ/E online news via a proxy server (Anonymouse), but it doesn't allow videos.

  • Muslim victim of Boston Marathon bombing sues Glenn Beck for defamation and slander
    • Marshalldoc 04/01/2014 at 4:55 pm

      Kudos to Mr. Alharbi for doing the one thing these idiot race-baiters fear the most... whatever might decrease the bloated incomes they make by peddling fear & hatred. I only hope he's not put off by a generous settlement offer since seeing headlines about Beck & the Blaze being forced to pay compensation & damages for lying (which they've been getting by with for far too many years without 'paying the piper') would be just f**king delicious!

  • Russian Annexation of Crimea, Israeli Annexation of Palestine
    • Marshalldoc 03/19/2014 at 9:43 pm

      "International Law" seems to be pretty much a term of convenience used to legitimize any stance one wishes to take. In this instance, you (and the West) claim that the Crimean vote to join Russia is 'illegal' under "International Law" while, Russia & Crimea insist that the Kiev putsch & resultant coup government (much like that of Honduras some years back) is 'illegal' under "International Law". And, since the World Court hasn't offered an unsolicited opinion (who's going to ask and be told it's their actions that are illegal?), nobody's convincingly wrong. I will note, however, contrary Juan's assertion that the Crimean vote wasn't legitimate, international observers from many outside nations found it to be just that; free, fair, without evidence of coercion or occupation. By the way, outside of assertions by those in the west regarding the 'Russian Invasion of Ukraine' has anyone seen a photo or video of demonstrably Russian forces anywhere they're not allowed by treaty? Seems odd to me, in these day's of ubiquitous cellphone cameras capable of HD quality video at the push of a button, that nobody's showing videos of Russian tanks streaming through the Fulda Gap... oops, sorry wrong cold war. And, while there are lots of photos of troops (both regular & otherwise) outfitted in Russian-type uniforms, operating Russian equipment, considering the prior Eastern Block nations still operate Russian equipment, it's hardly surprising that they all look Russian. Perhaps what we're really seeing here is another example of NeoCon overreach (they've never seen a regime they didn't think they could change for their better profits) and since USAID & IRI (among others) have been there "promoting democracy" for the six months prior to the revolt and funding nascent 'democrats' with millions of U.S. taxpayer dollars, what we're really seeing is another NeoCon plan playing out just like their prior plans (e.g.; Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Syria, etc., etc., etc., ad nauseum).

  • No Woman, No Drive (Saudi Satire Video)
    • Marshalldoc 10/28/2013 at 4:34 pm

      And who said Saudis have no sense of humor?

  • NSA abuses include Stalking ex-Girlfriends
    • Marshalldoc 08/24/2013 at 4:36 pm

      A variation of this tactic is employed by the U.S. military when investigating civilian deaths at the hands of our troops. First, deny the deaths were caused by us, blame the Taliban, al-Qaeda, the Islamic State of Iraq, Sunni militia, Shia militia, or the families themelves, etc. When confronted with incontrovertible proof of responsibility, maintain the deaths were 'collateral damage' and that others (see foregoing list) were the actual target but that their comrades spirited the bodies of the intended casualties away before the press got there. When grieving families go on TV stating that there were no [see foregoing list] present, only family members who are now dead, admit that 'some' civilians were killed in error but that the number claimed is actually twice as many as were really killed - inflated by the grieving families so as to profit from compensation for deaths that didn't happen. When confronted with proof that the deaths claimed are actually an under-count (after an inventory of body parts & identification of bodies and of who's still 'missing'), send a senior officer to make consolation payments of cash & goats in exchange for ongoing silence on the issue.

  • Yasiin Bey (aka Mos Def) force fed under standard Guantánamo Bay Concentration Camp procedure
    • Marshalldoc 07/09/2013 at 10:44 am

      I am worried that the image of tube feeding, as portrayed by the guards at Gitmo, may cause a major backlash against a valuable medical tool. Many patients, unable to take nutrition by mouth have feeding tubes placed via their nostrils into their stomachs. These tubes are very small (size 8 French - 'French' sizes are the measurement of the tube's circumference in millimeters), made of highly flexible silicone with a small weight in the end to help them pass. Insertion is typically not uncomfortable and the tubes stay in place between feedings. Similarly, tube feedings are administered in a specific fashion designed to prevent diarrhea or painful overdistention. With the proper medical indications & training, a feeding tube should not be 'torture' under any circumstance. A larger tube, a Naso-Gastric or NG Tube is anywhere from 10-18 F. and is used to aspirate gastric contents in patients whose intestinal tracts have ceased working (after bowel surgery for Eg.) or to remove gastric contents (e.g.; drug O.D.). They are often inserted during surgery (patient is unaware) but are usually well-tolerated (full disclosure - I had one in for a week after an operation & found the nasal/pharyngeal pain tolerable only with I.V. pain meds & local anesthetics, but it was necessary to allow bowel healing and to prevent gastric over-distention from natural secretions). I have placed them, or ordered them placed, in multitudes of patients over many years and found almost all of them tolerated them better than I did although having a large (18F) tube placed is uncomfortable, local anesthetics are very helpful in that circumstance. Regarding the situation at Gitmo, there's absolutely no assurance that the considerations afforded patients at civilian (or military) hospitals are afforded the detainees and I have no doubt that 'punative' tube placement is SOP. One need only listen to Amy Goodman's interview of al Jazeera reporter Sami al-Hajj to understand the deviation of Gitmo's procedures from standard medical practice.

      All this to say that if tube-feeding is recommended for you or a loved-one, do not think 'Gitmo'!

  • India-Pakistan Daily Border-Closing Ceremony, courtesy the Ministry of Silly Walks
    • Marshalldoc 06/23/2013 at 1:04 pm

      I think it's a great bit of performance art! I love the fact that, although they may be called on to fight each other that they can agree to coordinate on the ceremony and salute each other. It's a bit of the old Raj that continues and is clearly loved by the crowds who cheer their 'teams' and both sides are winners.

  • Shiraz, Iran: Timelapse Video
    • Marshalldoc 05/05/2013 at 8:27 pm

      Thanks for posting this Juan... truly a lovely city (also appreciate the info in Farhang's post).

  • Bad Camel
    • Marshalldoc 05/04/2013 at 7:49 pm

      Agree with all above... to boot, they laughted like idiots as the camel slimed their child's head with its tongue and then, when she trid to touch it's spit on the steering wheel, they're all 'euuwwww, don't touch that!' All-in-all, a pretty disgusting event.

  • The Changing map of Europe and the Middle East, 1000 - 2000 (10-min. Video)
    • Marshalldoc 04/29/2013 at 2:08 pm

      The detail is astonishing as is the degree of activity!

  • Jim Carrey: Fox 'News' is "A media colostomy bag... a public health issue" (Video)
    • Marshalldoc 04/03/2013 at 11:44 am

      Becoming the target of a coordinated vituperative Faux[NOT]News witch-hunt can only be construed as the highest accolade for expressing rational thought. Congratulations & Kudos to Jim Carry for achieving that recognition and for a really funny video!

  • The Top other thing Netanyahu Needs to Apologize For: The Gaza Blockade
    • Marshalldoc 03/25/2013 at 10:10 am

      Should I start holding my breath?

  • Uh, Segregated Buses aren't the Issue on the West Bank, Folks
    • Marshalldoc 03/13/2013 at 11:54 am

      IMHO, the segregated buses, while not an 'issue' as regards the overall dismal quality of life for Palestinians in or out of occupied territory (whatever you might consider those boundaries to be), they are without doubt prima facie evidence of Israel's construction of an apartheid state in the West Bank. As some others have observed, it's a potent symbol upon which to focus outrage and to motivate resistance... much like Rosa Parks' seat on the bus or the lunch counters on North Carolina.

  • Muslim Opposition to the Muslim Religious Right Grows, from Egypt to Bangladesh
    • Marshalldoc 03/03/2013 at 8:35 pm

      False equivalence Joe for Lowell, if one accepts that "Christianist" refers to Dominionists, as "Islamist" evidently refers to right-wing Muslims (Salafists & Wahhabis), there's no confusion. As far as the interplay between religion & politics, my take is that right wing Christians use religion to justify politics whereas MLK & Liberation Theology Catholics used religion to drive politics. It may all be relative... objects in space, etc.

    • Marshalldoc 03/03/2013 at 11:03 am with 2 replies

      First, this is an important article that helps clarify events in the Muslim world. One hopes (rhetorically, sadly) that the Islamophobes who continually deride the Muslim world for not rejecting extremism will take note.

      Secondly, as opposed to abandoning 'Islamist' why not adopt 'Christianist' to describe the right-wing Dominionists? ...just a thought.

  • Christian woman in Egypt Shoe-whacks Salafi Fundamentalist for Calling her a Harlot (Photo)
    • Marshalldoc 02/18/2013 at 8:43 pm

      Frankly, my hat's off to this feisty lady (and she is a Lady!) for defending her honor without hesitation and in a fashion considered most insulting in the Arab world. One wonders if the offender got the message. On a larger scale, one wonders how willing the Salafists/Wahhabis would be to destroy shops, beat or kill 'backsliders [including all Shia]', etc. if they were met with that kind of immediate stiff resistance. Just like any 'fundi' group imbued with self righteous indignation and backed (according to them) by 'god's inviolate word' they appear entirely unwilling to enter into meaningful negotiations regardless of what country we're discussing (Tunisia, Libya, Egypt, Saudi, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iraq, Mali, or Syria... among others)that would lead to peaceful cohabitation. I firmly believe that the overwhelming majority of mainstream Muslims want nothing more than to live their lives peacefully among their neighbors with neither bothering the other. However, the Muslim world seems to be under attack by the Fundi's (as if Westboro Baptist Church had free reign to determine how everyone in the U.S. must behave) and cannot seem to bring them under control. I fear for the nature of the 'final solution' to this dilemma.

  • Why HSBC "money-laundering" is Mostly about US Bullying Foreign Policy
    • Marshalldoc 12/14/2012 at 12:40 pm

      Louis,

      If you read the article Juan linked to his comments (link to blogs.reuters.com), you'll see that the issue of whether or not the U.S. could charge the banks criminally is irrelevant to the reason the laws are on the books; which is to create problems for Iran. Thus, destroying HSBC, while possible, wasn't the intent of the legislation or enforcement and would constitute unacceptable 'collateral damage'.

  • Muslims are no Different, or why Bill Maher's blood libel is Bigotry
    • Marshalldoc 09/25/2012 at 12:19 pm

      Thanks for calling a spade a spade Juan!

      You could write a similar article by changing the words 'Bill Maher' to 'Sam Harris'.

Showing comments 39 - 1
Page: 1

Tweet
Share
Reddit
Email

Primary Sidebar

Support Independent Journalism

Click here to donate via PayPal.

Personal checks should be made out to Juan Cole and sent to me at:

Juan Cole
P. O. Box 4218,
Ann Arbor, MI 48104-2548
USA
(Remember, make the checks out to “Juan Cole” or they can’t be cashed)

STAY INFORMED

Join our newsletter to have sharp analysis delivered to your inbox every day.
Warning! Social media will not reliably deliver Informed Comment to you. They are shadowbanning news sites, especially if "controversial."
To see new IC posts, please sign up for our email Newsletter.

Social Media

Bluesky | Instagram

Popular

  • Trumpism holds all Men are Created Unequal and most should be Denied Life, Liberty or the Pursuit of Happiness
  • Misreading and Misrepresenting Iran
  • Trump never saw a Wind Farm in China, but Beijing has half of all Installed Wind Capacity and will Eat America's Lunch in this Industry
  • Why China's Inaction on Palestine and Iran Weakens its Global Standing
  • The Trump Team's Purge of Pentagon Photos Raises Sinister Echoes from the Past

Gaza Yet Stands


Juan Cole's New Ebook at Amazon. Click Here to Buy
__________________________

Muhammad: Prophet of Peace amid the Clash of Empires



Click here to Buy Muhammad: Prophet of Peace amid the Clash of Empires.

The Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam


Click here to Buy The Rubaiyat.
Sign up for our newsletter

Informed Comment © 2025 All Rights Reserved